be lost or destroyed. Prior to commencing a search, investigators should ensure that they abide
by applicable laws or risk having seized exhibits declared inadmissible at trial.31 Identifying and
selecting relevant hardware has become a major part of an investigation.32
Indeed, while the proverbial “smoking gun” might be found in a subsequent review of seized
information, that information may be excluded as illegally obtained evidence.33 In the context of
electronic information, illegally obtained information is usually information that was obtained by
seizing more than what was specified in the warrant—for instance, if the warrant specifies data
and the device was (also) seized. Thus, while investigators may rely on a subsequent review of the
collected evidence, the threat of exclusion of that information as evidence operates as a check on
investigatory abuse.34
C. Examples of Good Practice
A considerable number of countries have prescribed—through legislation, regulation or court
decisions—the scope of searches of digital information.
In the United States, the courts have crafted procedures that differentiate between searching device
and data, and which require explicitness in the warrant, and that the default is a two-stage search
process. The US Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure—drafted, issued and approved by the federal
judiciary35—note the nuance between device and data stored on that device, stipulating that a
warrant must say whether it is authorizing “the seizure of electronic storage media or the seizure
or copying of electronically stored information”.36 The Rule continues by saying that, “[u]nless
otherwise specified, the warrant authorizes a later review of the media or information consistent
with the warrant” and that “[t]he time for executing the warrant […] refers to the seizure or on-site
copying of the media or information, and not to any later off-site copying or review”.37 The notes
to the Rules prepared by the Advisory Committee make it clear that, unless the warrant explicitly
specifies otherwise, the initial search done at the time of seizure need not be more than cursory,
with evidentiary reliance being placed on the subsequent review of the seized or copied materials.
That position has been reiterated and followed by the courts:
“Computers and other electronic storage media commonly contain such large
amounts of information that it is often impractical for law enforcement to review
all of the information during execution of the warrant at the search location. This
rule acknowledges the need for a two-step process: officers may seize or copy
the entire stage medium and review it later to determine what electronically
stored information falls within the scope of the warrant.”38
Page 99 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents