CHALLENGES TO SECURE ICS
PROCESS
use of USB drivers for file transferring,
an external contractor with an infected
laptop performing maintenance, and even
through a compromised software patch.
Optimal ICS security can be achieved by
strengthening the network, backed up
with appropriate policies and procedures
to prevent infiltration through these
vectors. In addition, having prepared and
practised response plans in case of an
incident minimises damage to the assets.
In order to bring people together in
a coordinated manner and have a
common understanding, organisations
must have governing processes in the
form of policies, standards, guidelines
and procedures in place. At the top
tier of formalised governance are
policies, which provide a generalised
overview of the organisation’s security
needs and direction. This is followed
by mandatory codes and standards for
compliance, as well as recommended
guidelines for best practice. Finally,
all of the above are distilled into
24
OPERATIONAL TECHNOLOGY CYBERSECURITY MASTERPLAN 2019
procedures for detailed steps on the
exact actions necessary to implement
a specific mechanism, control or solution.
Only through such formal documentation
can organisations produce a robust and
reliable security infrastructure by reducing
uncertainty and simplifying complexity.
While there are established global OT
cybersecurity standards and guidelines,
what is lacking is a set of localised
guidelines for OT stakeholders. Many
attack vectors can make the jump from
IT networks to OT systems, through the
Furthermore, ICS service support is often
via a single proprietary vendor. Protocols
and software codes are not shared with
customers; while maintenance hooks,
backdoors and other vulnerabilities are
unknown to users. As a result, patching
is irregular and only limited to ad-hoc
hot-fixes when vulnerabilities are
discovered. This leaves ICS operators
at the mercy of malicious actors, who
discover the vulnerabilities before they
are patched and carry out zero-day
attacks to compromise the system.
To aggravate matters, in some instances,
remote assistance through Virtual
Private Network (VPN) connection into
the system is required. If access is not
controlled and authenticated properly, or
if the link is not broken after maintenance,
this serves as a conduit for malicious
actors to exploit for entry into the system.
There is a need for system owners to work
with vendors to conduct regular code
reviews, enhance patch management,
and closely monitor remote access,
which are process measures that help
to better safeguard the cybersecurity
of ICS. In addition, as systems become
increasingly interconnected, more
protocols are likely to become open
source. This will mark a shift from the
old philosophy of “security through
obscurity” towards community threat
hunting and vulnerability reduction.
Michelle Knight
GM, Industrial Control Systems, Shell,
British-Dutch oil and gas company
“Shell has been on an ICS security journey
for more than a decade. ICS security
is one of the essential elements of
ensuring asset integrity and preventing
process safety incidents that could
potentially result in harm to people
or the environment. Safety is a deeply
held value and we are committed to
‘Goal Zero’ - No Harm, No Leaks, because
we care. Partnering with CSA, allows for
a unified country and industry approach
to cyber security. This is aimed at raising
awareness of the importance of cyber
security, strengthening existing controls, as
well as continuing to drive development
of new process and technology to manage
the ever-evolving threat environment we
operate in.”
OPERATIONAL TECHNOLOGY CYBERSECURITY MASTERPLAN 2019
25
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents