E/CN.15/2014/CRP.1
suspects at once, follow up on leads, and collect evidence against suspected child sexual abuse material offenders.347
However, in many countries, investigators have neither the training nor the equipment necessary to operate CETS or
similar tools.
Law enforcement agencies must also decide on how to best allocate scarce technological, financial and skilled
human resources.348 While consensus exists on the importance of protecting children from online offenders, law
enforcement agencies may face other resource claims with high priority, including terrorism, gangs, and organized crime
activities.
Access to third party data and other evidentiary challenges
In a cloud and remote server-based web environment, investigators are increasingly required to collect evidence
from third parties, such as Internet service providers, mobile telephone companies, social media and photo sharing
businesses and other third-party providers. Ordinarily, third parties delete data after a certain period in order to clear server
space for further use.349 The Cybercrime Study noted that the interplay between law enforcement and service providers is
particularly complex. National legal obligations and private sector data retention and disclosure polices vary widely by
country, industry and type of data. Service providers most commonly require due legal process for disclosure of customer
data. Accordingly, in many jurisdictions, a court order must be obtained in order to access electronic evidence from
service providers. In some cases, law enforcement may be able to obtain data directly, especially where this is facilitated
by informal partnerships between law enforcement authorities and service providers.
As an increasing number of crimes, including forms of child abuse and exploitation, involve digital evidence held
by third parties, it is critical that industry and governments work together to develop mechanisms for timely law
enforcement access to data in emergency situations, combined with fair and transparent legal processes for routine
investigations.
Establishing the means to conduct undercover investigations
ICT-facilitated abuse and exploitation offences commonly require undercover operations. Accordingly, first and
foremost, States need a clear legal framework for undercover or covert operations that takes full account of human rights
and rule of law standards.350 Many offenders may require their victims or co-perpetrators to engage in initiation rites, such
as the upload of child sexual abuse material, in order to dissuade undercover law enforcement agents. Policies and laws
must exist that clearly set out protections and liabilities for law enforcement officers who encounter such situations.
Undercover operations are most useful where States have clear criminalization provisions for inchoate crimes,
such as attempts or preparation for an offence. In the absence of such legal provisions, investigators cannot arrest wouldbe offenders until and unless the crime is completed, such as when the victim is actually abused or exploited. This
situation, in turn, considerably undermines the purpose of anti-child abuse and exploitation laws, policies and
operations.351
Increasing awareness and knowledge of the issues
Non-governmental organizations and members of civil society face the challenge of building upon the public’s
general, although sometimes vague, perception of and awareness of the risks that have been created by ICTs in the context
__________________
347
348
349
350
351
56
Harmon, B, 2012. Microsoft PhotoDNA Technology to Help Law Enforcement Fight Child Pornography, 19 March 2012.
Available at http://blogs.technet.com/b/microsoft_on_the_issues/archive/2012/03/19/microsoft-photodna-technology-to-helplaw-enforcement-fight-child-pornography.aspx.
See Etter, B., 2003.
For a review of typical data retention times, see UNODC.2013. P.147-148.
Bose, A., 2013.
Wei, W., 2010. Online Child Sexual Abuse Content: The Development of a Comprehensive, Transferable International
Internet Notice and Takedown System. Available at
https://www.iwf.org.uk/assets/media/resources/IWF%20Research%20Report_%20Development%20of%20an%20international
%20internet%20notice%20and%20takedown%20system.pdf.
V.14-03040
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents