A/76/136
2.2
Legality of a particular type of weapon
IHL stipulates that any means or method of warfare possessing one or more of
the following characteristics is inherently unlawful if:
(1)
it is of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering;
(2)
it is indiscriminate by nature, because it cannot be directed against a
specific military objective or its effects cannot be limited as required by IHL;
(3)
it is intended, or may be expected, to cause widespread, long-term or
severe damage to the natural environment; or
(4)
it is specifically prohibited by treaty or customary international law.
This is applicable to cyberspace and, therefore, to cyber means and methods of
warfare.
2.3
Legality of the manner in which the weapon is employed
With regard to the lawful use of cyber means and methods of warfare, the rules
and principles governing the conduct of hostilities must be respected. Belligerents
must in particular comply with the principles of distinction, proportionality and
precaution by:
distinguishing between military objectives on the one hand, and civilians
(1)
or civilian objects on the other hand and, in case of doubt, presume civilian status;
(2)
evaluating whether the incidental harm expected to be inflicted on the
civilian population or civilian objects would be excessive in relation to the concrete
and direct military advantage anticipated from that particular attack;;
(3)
taking all feasible precautions to spare civilians and civilian objects.
This is also applicable in cyberspace, when using cyber means and methods of
warfare. The aforementioned principles are applicable in particular to cyber
operations that amount to an attack within the meaning of IHL i.e. acts of violence
against the adversary, whether in offence or defence. What exactly constitutes a
‘cyber attack’ in an armed conflict has yet to be clarified. It encompasses at the very
least cyber operations that are reasonably expected to cause, directly or indirectly,
injury or death to persons, or physical damage or destruction to objects. The question,
how exactly data is protected in the absence of such physical damage, remains a
challenge. In practice, a responsible actor should generally be able to assess the
potential impact of their actions and any resulting damage. As this estimation
depends, amongst other things, largely on the information available at the time when
decisions about an operation are taken, the obligation to take all precautionary
measures practically possible to spare civilians and civilian objects plays a
particularly important role in the use of cyber means and methods of warfare.
3.
Other IHL provisions
Full compliance with IHL is not limited to the rules and principles governing
the conduct of hostilities. There are other specific rules of IHL that must be respected,
including when conducting military operations that do not qualify as an ‘attack’. For
example, certain categories of persons and objects are subject to special protection,
such as medical, religious or humanitarian personnel and objects, which must be
respected and protected in all circumstances.
This is also applicable to cyberspace. For cyber operations that are linked to any
of these specially protected persons or objects, or to other activities governed by IHL,
all of the relevant, specific rules must be observed.
94/142
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents