A/76/136
the technical and legal aspects of the incident, factoring in the geopolitical context,
and using the entire intelligence spectrum for the purpose of gathering information.
Using this approach, a state can attribute a cyber incident to another state or a private
actor, either publicly or not, and it can decide to take further political measures.
The process described above includes legal attribution, which ascertains
whether a cyber incident can be legally attributed to a state and if that state can be
held responsible under international law in accordance with the rules on state
responsibility; it also concerns how the injured state may respond (known as
countermeasures, see section 6.2). The conduct of any state organ or person exercising
an inherently governmental function is always legally attributable to the state
concerned. 229 If a cyber incident is carried out by a non-state actor, it can only be
attributed to a state under certain conditions. In such cases, state responsibility only
arises if the non-state actor acts on the instructions of a state, or under the direction
or control of state organs. 230 If this requirement is met, the conduct constitutes an act
by the state and is attributable to that state. The injured state is also permitted to take
countermeasures (see section 6.2). If the required interstate dimension is lacking
however, international law does not in principle permit countermeasures against
another state.
The decision to attribute conduct is at the discretion of the injured state and
there is no obligation under international law to disclose the information leading to
such a decision. Allegations of the organisation or implementation of an unlawful act
against another state should however be substantiated. 231
6.2. Countermeasures
A state may respond in different ways to unwelcome cyber activities carried out
by another state.
Retorsion allows states to respond to such activities regardless of whether
international law has been violated or not. It refers to unfriendly but lawful measures
in response to unwelcome acts by another state. Typical examples of retorsion include
refraining from signing a trade agreement that would benefit both parties, recalling
an ambassador, or breaking off diplomatic relations as a last resort.
In cases where an act violates international law and can be legally attributed to
a state, the injured state(s) may also take countermeasures in the form of reprisals,
provided that the applicable rules governing state responsibility are observed. 232
Although reprisals are contrary to international law, they are justified in response to
a prior breach of international law. However, such a countermeasure must not violate
certain fundamental substantive obligations such as the prohibition on the use of
force, fundamental human rights, most norms of international humanitarian law,
peremptory norms (jus cogens) and the obligation to respect diplomatic and consular
inviolability. 233 Military force, i.e. measures leading to loss of life and limb, are
therefore prohibited.
Countermeasures must impose a (legal) disadvantage aimed at prompting the
state concerned to cease its conduct that is in breach of international law and/or to
__________________
229
230
231
232
233
90/142
Art. 4 and Art. 5 ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful
Acts, August 2001.
Art. 8 ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts,
August 2001.
UN GGE 2015 Report, para. 28 f.
ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, August
2001. Unless prohibited by international law, countermeasures are subject to strict conditions.
Art. 50 ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts,
August 2001.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents