A/76/136
The 2015 GGE report recognized the applicability of the established jus in bello
principles of humanity, necessity, proportionality, and distinction in cyberspace. 284
The applicability of the jus in bello more broadly to States’ use of ICTs has been
reaffirmed by a large number of Member States. 285
The United States recognizes that cyber activities in the context of an armed
conflict may in certain circumstances constitute an “attack” for purposes of the
application of the jus in bello rules that govern the conduct of hostilities, including
the principles of humanity, necessity, proportionality, and distinction recognized in
the 2015 GGE report.
The United States has also elaborated on how these principles would apply to
cyber capabilities under an armed conflict. For example, the principle of distinction
requires that only legitimate military objectives be made the object of attack. In the
context of cyber capabilities used in armed conflict, the principle of distinction
requires that only legitimate military objectives be made the object of attack.
The principle of proportionality prohibits attacks that may be expected to cause
incidental loss to civilian life, injury to civilians, or damage to civilian objects which
would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage
anticipated. In the cyber context, this rule would require parties to a conflict to assess
the potential effects of cyber activities on both military and civilian infrastructure and
users, including shared physical infrastructure (such as a dam or a power grid) that
would affect civilians. In addition to the potential physical damage that a cyber
activity may cause, such as death or injury that may result from effects on critical
infrastructure, parties must assess the potential effects of a cyber attack on civilian
objects that are not military objectives, such as private, civilian computers that hold
no military significance but may be networked to military objectives.
In addition, when using cyber capabilities in armed conflict, States must
comply with their obligations under international humanitarian law related to the
protection of medical personnel and facilities. For example, medical personnel and
facilities must not be knowingly attacked or unnecessarily prevented from
discharging their proper functions, and parties to a conflict must take feasible
precautions to reduce the risk of incidental harm to the civilian population and other
protected persons and objects, including medical personnel and facilities.
The United States has specifically addressed how its international humanitarian
law obligations apply to cyberspace operations in the context of armed conflict in the
__________________
284
285
138/142
2015 GGE Report, para. 28(d).
See, e.g., Australia: International Cyber Engagement Strategy, Annex A: Australia’s position on
applies to State conduct in cyberspace (3 Oct. 2017), available at: https://www.dfat.gov.au/
publications/international-relations/international-cyber-engagement-strategy/aices/preliminary_
information/foreword.html; Australia: 2019 International Law Supplement, available at:
https://www.dfat.gov.au/publications/international-relations/international-cyber-engagementstrategy/aices/chapters/2019_international_law_supplement.html; Finland: National Positions,
International Law and Cyberspace, p.7 (2020), available at: https://front.un-arm.org/wp-content/
uploads/2020/10/finland-views-cyber-and-international-law-oct-2020.pdf; France: Ministry of
Defense, International Law Applied to Operations in Cyberspace, pp. 12–18 (Sept. 2019);
Netherlands: Letter of 5 July 2019 from the Minister of Foreign Affairs to the President of the
House of Representatives on the international legal order in cyberspace, Appendix: International
law in cyberspace, p. 5, available at: https://www.government.nl/ministries/ministry-of-foreignaffairs/documents/parliamentary-documents/2019/09/26/letter-to-the-parliament-on-theinternational-legal-order-in-cyberspace; New Zealand: The Application of International Law to
State Activity in Cyberspace, 1 Dec. 2020, available at: https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/media-andresources/ministry-statements-and-speeches/cyber-il/ UK: Attorney General Jeremy Wright,
Cyber and International Law in the 20th Century, 23 May 2018, available at:
https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/cyber-and-international-law-in-the-21st-century.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents