A/76/136
cultural system or the formulation of its foreign policy. 183 The constituent element of
coercion means that cyber activities that are merely influential or persuasive will not
qualify as illegal intervention.
Holding elections is an example of a matter within a State’s domaine réservé.
Thus, carrying out cyber operations with the intent of altering election results in
another State, for example by manipulating election systems or unduly influencing
public opinion through the dissemination of confidential information obtained
through cyber operations (‘hack and leak’), would be in violation of the prohibition
of intervention. Another example is a cyber operation deliberately causing a
temporary shutdown of the target State’s critical infrastructure, such as the power
supply or TV, radio, Internet or other telecommunications infrastructure in order to
compel that State to take a course of action.
3.3
Prohibition on the use of force
Key message:
A cyber operation may, depending on its scale and effects, violate the
prohibition on the threat or use of force in Article 2(4) of the UN Charter.
A cyber operation that is in violation of the prohibition on the threat or use of
force may, depending on its scale and effects, constitute an armed attack under
international law. An armed attack is the gravest form of the use of force.
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter prohibits the threat or use of force by a State
against the territorial integrity or political independence of another State, or in any
other manner inconsistent with the purposes of the UN. The prohibition is a norm of
customary international law. 184 It applies to any use of force, regardless of the
weapons or means employed. 185
There are only three exceptions to the prohibition on the use of force in the sense
that using force would not be in violation of international law: if the state on whose
territory the use of force takes place consents; if it is authorised by the Security
Council under Chapter VII of the UN Charter; or in the case of self-defence, in
response to an armed attack as recognised in Article 51 of the UN Charter.
Whether a cyber operation violates the prohibition on the threat or use of force
in Article 2(4) of the UN Charter depends on its scale and effects, physical or
otherwise. 186 Depending on its gravity, a cyber operation may also constitute an armed
attack under international law. 187 188 In accordance with the case law of the
International Court of Justice (ICJ), an armed attack is the gravest form of the use of
force. 189
__________________
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
21-09670
Nicaragua judgment, para. 205.
Nicaragua judgment, paras. 188–190.
See Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, ICJ, advisory opinion 8 July 1996, para. 39.
Nicaragua judgment, para. 195, where ICJ stated that the ‘scale and effects’ are to be considered when
assessing whether particular actions constitute an ‘armed attack’. The factors are equally useful and
logical when determining whether a cyber operation constitutes the use of force according to
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter.
Nicaragua judgment, para. 195.
A cyber operation that constitutes an armed attack on a State under international law triggers the right
to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter. See Section 5 Response measures in this paper.
Nicaragua judgment, para. 191: ‘[. . .] it will be necessary to distinguish the most grave forms of the
use of force (those constituting an armed attack) from other less grave forms’.
69/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents