on the UN level for greater legal clarity and the fundamental readiness of countries to seek and create that clarity are the groups of cyber experts convoked by the UN General Assembly (UN GGE). Their reports from 2013 and 2015 recognize explicitly the application of international law in cyber space. The 2017 group did not however manage to agree on the final report and as of 2018 the countries did not get closer to a consensus on how international law is to be applied in cyber space. At the OSCE level, confidence building measures have been agreed upon in 2013 and 2016 to reduce the risk of conflict through exchange of information and cooperation.31 As a key academic contribution, a manual on international law applicable to cyber operations was published in February 2017 under the aegis of the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence. The Tallinn Manual 2.032 deals with cyber operations as a component in relations between countries in the context of international law, giving practical guidance to countries. An ever more comprehensive legal environment for market participants With the growing importance of the digital environment and increased risks comes pressure and need to regulate the field to a greater extent at the EU level and within Estonia. Estonia’s opportunity here is to keep the volume of regulations under control, as an effect of number of processes and procedures is that the total complexity of the rules increases – each new regulation is more precise and thorough than the previous one. The complexity of the state’s IT solutions grows with the volume of regulations and IT itself becomes intrinsically more complex. On one hand, regulations must contribute to the substantive implementation of data security and ensure the security of society based on the weighty role played by the digital environment in the functioning of society. At the same time, it is also a challenge for cross-sectoral cooperation and pressure on Estonia’s speed and flexibility, making it more complicated to resolve problems using new methods and Estonia’s own rules, which has to some extent been the precondition for the success stories to date. Challenges posed by Internet freedom All over the world, the availability of the internet has increased people’s access to information and besides economic growth, it has also created greater transparency and created the possibility for better and less costly provision of public services, participation of civil society in decision-making processes, and raised 31 The value of the OSCE process is that it encompasses countries with very different views (including EU, the US and Russia). 32 Tallinn Manual 2.0 on the International Law Applicable to Cyber Operations. Cambridge University Press, 2017. 23

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents