engagement of responsible caregivers in the lives of children
is widely recognized as a crucial factor.338
Opportunities to enhance the fight
against ICT-facilitated child abuse and
exploitation
Balancing child protection with human rights
One of the most challenging issues that governments face in
preventing and combating ICT-facilitated child abuse and
exploitation is that of establishing an equitable balance
between child online safety and the safeguarding of internationally recognized human rights.
As the Cybercrime Study notes, computer content-related
crimes, such as the ones discussed in the current study, may
engage treaty-based rights such as the right to freedom of
expression and the positive obligations of states to ensure
security of the person and protection from physical harm.
Content available on the Internet is, in principle, subject to
the same human rights regime as traditional media, such as
printed matter and speech.339 Resolution 20/8 of the United
Nations Human Rights Council affirms “that the same rights
that people have offline must also be protected online, in particular freedom of expression, which is applicable regardless
of frontiers and through any media of one’s choice”.340
Nonetheless, online content has particular features—
including the fact that the impact and longevity of information can be multiplied when placed on the Internet, that
content is easily accessible to minors, and that developments
in social media and user-generated Internet content have
begun to challenge traditional monopolies over information.
As a result, the interpretation of human rights provisions
must take into account the specific nature of the Internet as a
means of imparting information.341
The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the promotion
and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and
338
Commentary at the Informal Expert Group Meeting on the
Effects of Information and Communication Technologies on the
Abuse and Exploitation of Children. Vienna, 23-26 September
2013.
339
See UNODC, 2013. Pp. 107-116.
340
United Nations Human Rights Council, 2012. Resolution
20/8 on The promotion, protection and enjoyment of human rights
on the Internet [A/HRC/RES/20/8].
341
UNODC, 2013. P. 109.
expression, identifies four forms of expression that are
required to be prohibited by international law: child pornography; direct and public incitement to commit genocide;
advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence; and
incitement to terrorism.342
Thus, whereas the human rights position on the prohibition of child sexual abuse material is clear, restrictions on
some other forms of content and acts discussed in this study,
such as “sexting”, or locating publicly available information
on an individual, is significantly less clear from a human rights
perspective. As governments seek to develop effective
responses to the whole range of forms of ICT-facilitated
abuse and exploitation, it is important that they do so in full
conformity with international human rights standards—both
as they relate to victims and perpetrators.
In this respect, one starting point is the development of
international consensus in the form of international “block”
lists, standards, and policy recommendations, where available. Industry associations can a play role in promoting and
achieving such consensus. Operator members of the GSMA
Mobile Alliance against Child Sexual Abuse Content, for
example, commit to implementing blocks on lists of child
sexual abuse material URLs only as defined by credible third
parties—including the IWF CAIC list343 and the INTERPOL
“worst of ” list. The GSMA’s role in this area is to promote this
approach as a good practice by, for instance, facilitating new
members’ access to the lists by brokering relationships with
the IWF and/or INTERPOL, sharing toolkits on implementation, and advocating for clear legislative frameworks where
necessary.
Ensuring that legislation keeps pace with
technological innovation
A further challenge encountered by governments consists of
enacting laws that keep pace with advances in technology.
Many States have updated their computer-crime laws to
address innovations in ICTs. In order to have a lasting and
sustained effect, however, revisions to existing laws and new
laws must be drafted in a flexible way and in a “technologyneutral” manner, so as to keep up with technological innovation without needing constant reform. Laws and international
342
See United Nations General Assembly, 2011. Promotion and
protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression. Note by the
Secretary-General [A/66/290].
343
https://www.iwf.org.uk/members/member-policies/url-list/
testing-policy
III.
Combating the problem 55
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents