Research on the interdependencies between society’s perceived risks and actual harms would be especially valuable for
policymakers faced with the difficult task of allocating scarce
resources. Along similar lines, research on the ways in which
certain intrinsic and extrinsic factors affect children’s vulnerability to abuse and exploitation would also be of use in
e vidence-based policymaking.354
Equally, research on offender profiles is also needed. Of
particular interest in this regard is the relationship between
contact and non-contact abusers, and an understanding of
the causal impact that contact and non-contact abuse have on
each other.
Research on the demand side is also essential in order to
prevent commercial sexual abuse and exploitation of children. For instance, some regions of the United States have
experimented with extended education programmes for firsttime prostitution offenders.355 Likewise, several European
countries are pioneering various programmes to deter commercial sexual exploitation of children.356 With respect to
child sex abuse and exploitation in the travel and tourism
industries, various education campaigns have been initiated
to curb demand. For example, NGOs have executed multimedia campaigns to deter sex tourists at places in airports, inflight videos, tourist magazines, and billboards in tourist
areas.357
Developing policy guidance on harmful
conduct committed by youth
With regard to cyberbullying, recent successful policies have
aimed at informing, training and supporting parents, teachers
and children in coping with such conduct and working with
perpetrators, especially child bullies. With respect to exposure to harmful content, attention has focused on educating
parents about the hazards associated with video games, social
media sites and mobile apps, and the need for parents to
Bose, A., 2013.
See Shively, M., et al., 2008. , Final Report on the Evaluation of
the First Offender Prostitution Program. Available at https://www.
ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/221894.pdf.
356
See Scoular, J., 2004. “Criminalising ‘Punters’: Evaluating the
Swedish Position on Prostitution”, Journal of Social Welfare and
Family Law, 26:195-210; Marinova, N. K., James, P., 2012. “The
Tragedy of Human Trafficking: Competing Theories and Evidence”,
Foreign Policy Analysis 8:231-253.
357
World Vision. World Vision’s Work on Sex Tourism to Prevent
Sex Tourism. Available at http://www.worldvision.org/worldvision/pr.nsf/stable/child_sex_tourism_wvwork.
354
355
profoundly and personally engage with their children in order
to effectively protect them.
One of the most challenging issues in the formation of
policy is the issue of child exploitation offences committed by
other youth. Some crimes such as cyberenticement by definition involve an adult offender and a minor victim. However,
other child sexual abuse material offences, commercial sexual
exploitation of children, cyberstalking and cyberbullying,
and exposing children to harmful content can be executed by
minors. In some child-on-child offences, the youth perpetrating the harmful conduct acts much such as an adult offender.
For example, children who engage other children in commercial sexual exploitation are creating harm that is not likely to
be mitigated by the young age of the perpetrator. In other
cases, the impact of peer-on-peer conduct such as sexting is
less clear. Such newly emerging trends and phenomena need
to be better understood through qualitative and quantitative
research, with a view to producing clear policy guidance.
States also have a strong interest in treating young
offenders differently from adult offenders, in particular when
it comes to applying mandatory minimum sentences or to
being registered as a sex offender. In charting a path on this
issue, policymakers should consider whether or not the
nature of the act itself and the harm arising from it, both for
the victim and society at large, is altered by the fact that the
offence in question was committed by a minor. In formulating
such policies, a multidisciplinary approach that draws on
research findings and best practices from social science, legal
policy and public policy is highly advisable.
Mitigating negative effects by the
private sector
Many private sector businesses and technology companies
are motivated by a strong sense of corporate social responsibility and a desire to comply with internationally recognized
human rights standards. Such standards can also apply to
investment in combatting ICT-facilitated child abuse and
exploitation, and the links between social responsibility,
human rights, and child protection should be increasingly
emphasized.
58 STUDY ON THE EFFECTS OF NEW INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES ON THE ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents