cooperation mechanisms must also address the need for
timely access to information across national boundaries.
Finally, legislators themselves must receive sufficient training
and guidance on making sound decisions in the formulation
of effective laws.
Establishing specialized units with dedicated
personnel
Specially trained and dedicated personnel with relevant skills
are crucial in combatting ICT-facilitated child abuse and
exploitation. The Cybercrime Study noted that less than one
per cent of all police are specialists in cybercrime.344 In turn,
only a part of that percentage may be specially trained and
dedicated to investigating the use of ICTs in child exploitation offences. Consequently, many child exploitation investigations may not involve digital forensic examiners and the
expertise these could bring to the investigations.
Investigators specialized in child abuse and exploitation
tend to be more effective in collecting evidence from physical
crime scenes. For instance, in addition to searching for child
sexual abuse material, such as evidence on computers and
related technology, specialized investigators may also search
the offender’s home more effectively for other related evidence, such as toys or items used to subdue child victims.
Such evidence could strengthen and support digital evidence
against a suspect. When and where specialized and dedicated
units exist, members should also receive training on interviewing child victims and witnesses, including topics such as
how to use age-appropriate settings for interviews, and the
use of dolls and drawings to elicit details from young children
with limited vocabularies.
Experienced and dedicated personnel also tend to develop
transnational networks of contacts that work on child exploitation issues. Resulting relationships may facilitate cooperation on an informal basis in preparation for subsequent
transnational investigations.345
Additionally, specialized personnel can also better identify
and respond to common defences employed by suspects during judicial proceedings, such as claims that “someone else
did it” using their equipment, that contraband material was
downloaded by mistake, or that the perpetrator was unaware
that the victim was a minor.
UNODC. 2013. P.154.
Interview with Michael Moran, Chief Investigator, Crimes
Against Children Unit, INTERPOL, 14 March 2012.
344
345
At trial stage, ICT-specialized prosecutors are able to more
clearly and persuasively present technical evidence to judges
and juries. They may, for example, develop skills in structuring the order of witnesses called and in organizing the conduct of witness examination to present technical evidence at a
digestible rate.
Accessing state-of-the-art technological
resources
In order to keep pace with technological innovation and
effectively combat child exploitation, investigators require
access to state-of-the-art equipment. Cutting-edge techno
logy devices and software, including high-quality equipment
for storing and processing data, enable investigators to operate the equipment that many criminals use in perpetrating
child abuse and exploitation crimes.346 Continuous training
on new tools and emerging technologies are also imperative.
As the costs of technology decrease, offenders can amass
ever greater data-storage capacities. As a result, investigators
may increasingly require access to sophisticated case management software. In 2002, for example, Microsoft developed the
Child Exploitation Tracking System (CETS) to help law
enforcement agencies efficiently track hundreds of suspects at
once, follow up on leads, and collect evidence against suspected child sexual abuse material offenders.347 However, in
many countries, investigators have neither the training nor
the equipment necessary to operate CETS or similar tools.
Law enforcement agencies must also decide on how to
best allocate scarce technological, financial and skilled human
resources.348 While consensus exists on the importance of
protecting children from online offenders, law enforcement
agencies may face other resource claims with high priority,
including terrorism, gangs, and organized crime activities.
Access to third-party data and other
evidentiary challenges
In a cloud and remote server-based web environment, investigators are increasingly required to collect evidence from third
parties, such as Internet service providers, mobile telephone
346
Offenders may use larger quantities of data due to the decrease
in price of external storage devices and additional virtual storage
capacity available in cloud environments.
347
Harmon, B., 2012. Microsoft PhotoDNA Technology to Help
Law Enforcement Fight Child Pornography, 19 March 2012. Available
at http://blogs.technet.com/b/microsoft_on_the_issues/
archive/2012/03/19/microsoft-photodna-technology-to-help-lawenforcement-fight-child-pornography.aspx.
348
See Etter, B., 2003.
56 STUDY ON THE EFFECTS OF NEW INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES ON THE ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents