facilitated abuse and exploitation. At the same time, however, the importance of victim identification and protection,
as well as the need for timely information sharing has
resulted in the development of effective cooperation mechanisms at the operational law enforcement, as well as strategic
levels.
With regard to volatile computer data and at-risk children,
both of which require immediate action by law enforcement,
police often need to attain information or assistance faster
than they could via formal channels, such as mutual legal
assistance. Informal direct communication between police
officers can provide a valuable supplement to formal procedures. While waiting for official responses to information
requests, police can advise each other on how to follow up
time-sensitive leads. They may also be able to inform each
other about cultural norms and local practices, which may
facilitate cross-border investigations.301
An example of a successful international
law enforcement operation
Particularly with regard to child sexual abuse material,
international law enforcement operations have been
instrumental in increasing arrests and convictions and
bringing awareness of the crime. One of the first such
operations, Operation Avalanche as it was called in the
United States, was initiated in 1999 and was set up to
examine the 35,000 names registered to a pornography
web-portal database. The United States Federal Bureau
of Investigation shared the details of subscribers from
overseas with law enforcement agencies in the relevant
countries and operations were initiated in Canada,
Germany, Ireland, Switzerland and the United
Kingdom. In total, 59 countries were involved in this
investigation. This type of cooperation has been replicated successfully many times since and does not generally involve sustained coordination or action, or
requests for legal assistance through formal or informal
channels. Sustained joint operations as well as mutual
legal assistance procedures are types of international
cooperation that are frequently more complicated and
time consuming to implement.
The Cybercrime Study reported that, while many countries engage in informal cooperation in cybercrime cases, the
range of investigative actions that can be provided through
such channels varies considerably, as well as the existence of
clear policies on its use. One major problem in the context of
informal cooperation is the fact that many countries prohibit
the use of evidence obtained through such informal channels
in the context of judicial proceedings. Nevertheless, “24/7”
networks in particular hold a considerable potential for
streamlining informal cooperation and facilitating formal
cooperation; however, they still tend to be used infrequently
in the investigation and prosecution of transnational cybercrime. The Cybercrime Study also concluded that, globally,
divergences in the scope of cooperation provisions contained
in multilateral and bilateral instruments, a lack of response
time obligation, multiple informal law enforcement networks
and variance in cooperation safeguards represent significant
challenges to effective international cooperation regarding
electronic evidence in criminal matters.302
At the strategic level, the formation of multi-agency partnerships has emerged as a common practice for combating
technology-facilitated crimes against children. Groups such
as the Virtual Global Task Force (VGT), the Financial
Coalition against Child Pornography (FCACP), and the
International Association of Internet Hotlines (INHOPE)
bring together different agencies from multiple countries to
work on specific child exploitation issues. Such initiatives aim
to harness the ideas and resources of multiple entities, resulting in more robust policy and programme initiatives.303
Forums for information-sharing and joint problem-solving
are also examples of commonly adopted practices for
combating online child abuse and exploitation.
Working groups sponsored by private entities, individual
States, and regional and international coalitions constitute
important opportunities for detailed technical information
exchange. The INTERPOL Specialist Group on Crimes
Against Children, for example, brings together global
experts to share best practices. Individuals involved benefit
from opportunities for developing informal relationships
that may facilitate fast and easy cross-border cooperation in
the future.304
UNODC, 2013. Pp. 197-215,
See, for example, http://www.inhope.org/gns/Internetconcerns/overview-of-the-problem/illegal-content.aspx; http://
www.virtualglobaltaskforce.com/what-we-do/.
304
http://www.interpol.int/Crime-areas/Crimes-againstchildren/Crimes-against-children.
302
303
301
UNODC, 2013. Pp. 208-215.
48 STUDY ON THE EFFECTS OF NEW INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES ON THE ABUSE AND EXPLOITATION OF CHILDREN
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents