A/76/136
otherwise. 221 This means that the threshold for a breach of the non-intervention
principle is significantly higher than that for a violation of state sovereignty.
The prohibition of intervention is also applicable to cyberspace. This means that
in cyberspace, an unlawful act of interference by one state in the political or economic
affairs of another may, in addition to constituting a violation of sovereignty, also
breach the non-intervention principle under international law if the respective
requirements are fulfilled. 222 The distinction between exerting influence, which is
permissible, and coercion, which is not, must be determined on a case-by-case basis.
This is particularly true of economic coercion, which could be the case if a company
that is systemically relevant was paralysed through a cyber operation. An assessment
of whether the operation can be deemed coercive in nature, and thereby be in breach
of the non-intervention principle, can only be made on a case-by-case basis.
4.
Prohibition on the use of force and the right of self-defence
One of the key founding principles of the UN Charter is the prohibition on the
use of force (Art. 2 para. 4). There are only two exceptions: if the use of force is
authorised by the UN Security Council (Art. 42) or if the strict conditions under which
the right of self-defence may be exercised are fulfilled (Art. 51).
The prohibition on the use of force and the right of self-defence are also
applicable to cyberspace. The right of self-defence may only be exercised if an armed
attack occurs first. In accordance with ICJ case law, not every violation of the
prohibition on the use of force constitutes an armed attack, but only its gravest form.
In order to qualify, the scale and effect of the attack must reach a certain threshold of
gravity. 223 The ICJ has also determined that an armed attack does not necessarily have
to involve kinetic military action or the use of weapons because the means by which
an attack is perpetrated is not the decisive factor. 224 A state is permitted to exercise its
right of self-defence in response to a cyber incident if the incident amounts in scale
and effect to that of a kinetic operation in terms of inflicting death or serious injury
to persons, or extensive material damage to objects. There are no binding quantitative
or qualitative guidelines as to when the threshold of an armed attack in terms of scale
and effect has been reached. Current discussions on how to define an armed attack in
cyberspace are focusing on attacks on critical infrastructure (e.g. nuclear power
plants, power grids) which reach the required threshold in terms of scale and effect
i.e. serious injury to persons and/or extensive damage to objects.
The purpose of the UN Charter must guide the interpretation of the prohibition
on the use of force and the right to exercise self-defence in the face of an armed attack.
The Charter’s objective is to maintain and, where necessary, restore international
peace and security. Consequently, even if an armed attack occurs, a state is only
permitted to undertake countermeasures that are necessary and proportionate in order
to repel the attack. The right of self-defence only applies if the UN Security Council
has not taken the necessary measures to maintain international peace and security
(Art. 51 UN Charter). If the actions taken in self-defence exceed this framework, the
state itself is in breach of the prohibition on the use of force. If the threshold for an
armed attack has not been reached, states can have recourse to immediate and
proportionate non-violent countermeasures (see section 6.2).
__________________
221
222
223
224
88/142
Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua, ICJ Reports 1986, para. 202.
Explanatory notes to the Ordinance on Military Cyber Defence, SR 510.921.
Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua, ICJ Reports 1986, para. 195.
Advisory Opinion on the Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, ICJ Reports 1996,
para. 39.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents