A/AC.290/2021/INF/2
Japan
Statement by Mr. AKAHORI Takeshi, Ambassador for Cyber Policy of the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs of Japan,
at the third substantive session of the OEWG on ICTs
(Explanation of Position before adoption)
March 12, 2021
The Government of Japan would like to express its deep appreciation and great
respect to Ambassador Jurg Lauber, Chair of the Open-ended working group on
developments in the field of information and telecommunications in the context of
international security (OEWG), for preparing the draft Fin al Substantive Report
before us. Japan also expresses its gratitude to Under-Secretary-General Nakamitsu
and all the members of UN Secretariat and support team who supported our process
in difficult times.
Japan supports the adoption of the draft as a Final Substantive Report.
As mentioned in the draft, the OEWG conducted its work building upon and
reaffirming the framework provided by the three consensus reports of the groups of
governmental experts (GGEs) and succeeded in reaching certain conclusions and
recommendations to promote an open, fair and secure cyberspace.
Japan kept its promise made at the first substantive session of the working group
and participated actively and constructively in all formal and informal sessions and
multi-stakeholder events. Japan also provided various proposals to help build
additional layers of understanding among States on cybersecurity. The joint
proposal on medical services and medical facilities and its own proposal on a
guidance to the existing norm on supply chain integrity are only some examples.
Our support for the adoption of the draft does not mean that Japan is satisfied with
the draft in its entirety. Japan strongly prefers to see more detailed language
supported by many delegations in the International Law sect ion of the report. From
the beginning of the process, Japan has been proposing to include language
explicitly affirming the applicability of State responsibility for internationally
wrongful acts, the inherent right of self-defense recognized in the UN Charter, and
International Humanitarian Law. While I heard some delegations claim ing that there
is a lack of consensus on how international law applies in cyberspace, I have not
heard convincing arguments explaining why those principles or areas of
international law are not applicable in the ICT environment. On the contrary, for
example, we had rich inputs on why we should affirm the applicability of
International Humanitarian Law from various stakeholders including ICRC and
academia.
Japan is not happy that the draft, which was purported to include only consensus
language, includes in paragraph 80 one perspective which was quite controversial.
The idea of the possibility of additional legally binding obligations was strongly
opposed by many delegations including mine and should have been left in the
Chair’s summary of discussions, if at all.
Japan urges States putting forward the idea of new binding obligations to
thoroughly consider how international law applies in cyberspace before making
proposals. To give just one example, a new legally binding instrument would have
no meaning without reaffirmation that international customary law on State
21-04015
51/91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents