A/AC.290/2021/INF/2
Liechtenstein
Open-ended Working Group on Developments in the Field of Information and
Telecommunications in the Context of International Security
Explanation of Position on the Report of the Open -ended Working Group
12 March 2021
Chairperson,
I am taking the floor in explanation of position on the report of the Open-ended Working
Group. If we are in a position to do so today that is primarily to the credit of the
Chairperson’s unwavering commitment to bringing our fruitful discussions to a
substantive conclusion, against the difficult odds of a pandemic, a heavily polarized
political landscape and serious limitations in the intergovernmental mandate.
Liechtenstein thanks the Chairperson and the Secretariat for their tremendous efforts
leading us to an outcome. The discrepancy between the content of the intergovernmental
discussions and the substantive results of the Open-ended Working Group does not
reflect a lack of effort. It is rooted in the format of this process and its decision -making
modalities which favor containment over progress and minority restraint over majority
aspiration. Unfortunately, the intergovernmental mandate for the next iteration of the
Open-ended Working Group is even more affected by these flaws, pointing to the
conclusion that the process in this form may have outlived its purpose.
Chairperson,
Liechtenstein regrets that the report falls short in a number of ways. While the
report reaffirms the acquis of past agreements, it fails to adequately reflect the fact
that cyberspace is governed by international law, including the UN Charter in its
entirely, international human rights law and international humanitarian law. The
future of warfare will be increasingly characterized by its cyber dimension and it is
undeniable that cyber warfare can have very significant humanitarian consequences.
The Open-ended Working Group has benefitted from expert opinions on that matter,
in particular from the ICRC. That it should not be possible to adequately reflect the
applicability of international humanitarian law to cyberspace in its report
undermines the credibility of our collective effort. It is also regrettable that the
obvious problem of ensuring accountability for violations of international law in
cyberspace, both from a perspective of State and individual criminal responsibility,
and linked to it the inherent challenges of attribution, are missing from the report.
That these questions could not be identified as future areas for discussion also
points to the limits of the process. Liechtenstein reiterates its position that is sees no
need to elaborate additional legal obligations, in particular as long as our
discussions on how to apply existing international law does not advance.
Chairperson,
Consensus should always be the aspiration in our multilateral engagement, but to
equate it with a universal veto power is a conceptual aberration that future
discussions on cybersecurity need to steer clear of. In addition, these discussions
should be conducted on the basis of the best available knowledge, for which the
meaningful engagement with civil society, academia and the private sector is
indispensable. On this basis, Liechtenstein will reevaluate it future engagement in
the framework of the Open-ended Working Group. Liechtenstein supports the
initiative for a Programme of Action and considers it an alternative to advance cyber
security that can be commensurate to the aspirations of a broad majority in the
membership to make tangible progress towards compliance with international law
and increased collective security, and to sustain an inclusive dialogue with all
relevant stakeholders to that effect.
21-04015
53/91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents