A/AC.290/2021/INF/2 Australia welcomes the unequivocal reaffirmation of the framework of responsible state behaviour (international law, norms, confidence building measures and capacity building) as endorsed by all countries in General Assembly Resolution 70/237 (pp7-8). As well as recognition that each of these elements is interrelated and mutually reenforcing (pp13). Australia welcomes the re-affirmation that international law, and in particular, the UN Charter, applies to States’ activities in cyberspace (p34). As well as recognition that States’ need to deepen their understanding of how particular principles of international law apply to the use of ICTs, and, in turn, the emphasis on the importance of capacity building to ensure all countries can contribute to building consensus and deepening common understandings (pp36-37;39-40; 54; 59-60). Australia welcomes the Report’s clarity on the relationship between international law which is binding, and non-binding norms (p24-25); in particular, in paragraph 25 that “norms do not replace or alter States’ obligations or rights under international law” … “but rather provide additional specific guida nce on what constitutes responsible State behaviour” in cyberspace. Consistent with this, we understand the reference to “obligations” in paragraph 17 to refer to inter national legal obligations. Australia regrets that the order of the international law and norms sections was reversed in the final report (at request of the Chinese delegation); given international law is binding, and norms are voluntary, Australia would have preferred the international law section to have preceded the norms section – but not at the cost of consensus. Australia welcomes the call for countries to refrain from use of ICTs not in accordance with international law and the norms for responsib le state behaviour (pp24, pp34). In this regard, Australia understands “international law” to be the entire corpus of international law, and “the norms” to be the 11 norms consensually endorsed in General Assembly Resolution 70/237. Australia welcomes that the OEWG has added to previous agreements by confirming the UN Charter obligation to settle disputes by peaceful me ans applies in cyberspace (pp35). We regret that a small number of delegations continued to resist specific acknowledgement in the report that international humanitarian law (IHL) applies to cyber activities in armed conflict. Australia understands that th ese delegations did not object to the application of IHL per se, but rather objected to inclusion of such a reference in the report on the basis that such a reference would encourage militarisation of cyberspace. In this regard, Australia recalls the posit ion taken by the ICRC that recognition of the application of IHL neither encourages militarisation, nor legitimises resort to conflict in any domain. We note also acknowledgment in the report that “the use of ICTs in future conflict between states is becoming more likely” (pp16). While Australia regrets its absence in the Substantive Report, we nevertheless welcome references to IHL in the Chair’s Summary (especially those in pp12). Australia welcomes confirmation that the healthcare infrastructure is c onsidered critical infrastructure for the purpose of the existing critical infrastructure norms (p26). In this regard, Australia understands the “existing critical infrastructure norms” to be norms at paragraph 13 (f) and (g) of the 2015 GGE Report (A/70/1 74) as consensually endorsed in General Assembly Resolution 70/237. Typographical note: the full stop in the penultimate line of p26 shoul d be a comma. 8/91 21-04015

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents