Audit objectives, scope and criteria
4.3.3.
The aim of an audit is to review and assess:
the risk identification and assessment;
design and complexity (including the system and security architectures);
any available assurance reports on support or outsourced services;
controls selection;
actual implementation and effectiveness of controls for a system; and
supporting information security documentation.
4.3.4.
Only information that is verifiable should be accepted as audit evidence. Audit evidence should be recorded.
Audit outcome
4.3.5.
The outcome of an audit is a report of compliance and control effectiveness for the certification authority outlining areas of non-compliance for a
system and any suggested remediation actions.
4.3.6.
Part of this audit is an assessment of whether the control systems adequately identify and address risk and information security requirements.
Who can assist with an audit
4.3.7.
A number of other agencies and personnel within agencies are often consulted during an audit. Agencies or personnel that can be consulted on
physical security aspects of information security may include:
The NZSIS for Physical Security;
GCSB for TOP SECRET sites and Sensitive Compartmented Information Facilities (SCIFs);
MFAT for systems located at overseas posts and missions;
The Chief Security Officer (CSO) may be consulted on personnel and physical security aspects of information security;
The CISO, ITSM or communications security officer may be consulted on COMSEC aspects of information security; and
The ITSM and System Owner on aspects of secure system design configuration and operation.
Independent audits
4.3.8.
An audit may be conducted by agency auditors or an independent security organisation.
Audit Evidence
4.3.9.
Audit evidence can be obtained from documentation described in Chapter 5 – Information Security Documentation.
Other sources may include:
Source
Agency Strategies and Statements of Intent.
Any additional process documentation referenced in the documentation
described in the NZISM Chapter 5.
Third party service provider agreements.
Independent risk assessments or security evaluations, such as penetration
tests by an internal team or an external organization.
The agency risk identification and assessment process.
Any internal audit reports, assessments and reviews.
Any statements of applicability.
Any relevant incident reports.
Audit evidence reliability
4.3.10. The reliability of audit evidence is influenced by its source, nature and the circumstances under which the evidence is gathered. In general terms
documentary evidence is more reliable than oral evidence, self-generated evidence less reliable than evidence gathered elsewhere and externally
generated evidence is more reliable than internally generated evidence as internally generated evidence may be more susceptible to selective
presentation.
4.3.11. Confirmation should be obtained that:
Risk owners have been identified; and
Each risk owner has sufficient accountability and authority to manage their identified risks.
4.3.12. Audit evidence can be gathered through the following methods in order of preference:
Method
Description
Inspection
Physical inspections can provide an independent confirmation of the physical condition of the site or systems, its implementation
and its management.
Analytical review
Reviews of records and documents will provide evidence of varying degrees of reliability depending on their nature and source. A
review of the risk identification and selection of risk treatments is invaluable.
34
Version_3.5__January-2022
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents