Cybersecurity guide for developing countries
IV.1.4.3
Regulating spam
There are two opposing methods of regulating spam: the opt-in approach and the opt-out approach.
The opt-in approach, which is also called permission marketing, is more respectful of the internet user
in that it consists in sending him only the targeted advertising which he has explicitly agreed to
receive, by either selecting or deselecting a box; agreement may also be inferred, but in that case the
visitor must be clearly informed of the commercial nature and of the consequences of subscription.
The opt-out method consists in “unsubscribing” and establishes the right to refuse to receive messages
a posteriori. Every advertisement sent must give the recipient the possibility of unsubscribing from the
list. Opt-out records can be constituted lawfully (for example by buying an opt-in list) or harvested
using a random procedure.
Swiss and American lawmakers have chosen the opt-out approach, whereas the European Union tends
to favour the opt-in approach, as demonstrated by Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of
personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector (Directive on
privacy and electronic communications).
Because spammers tend to act anonymously and from abroad, litigation is expensive and complicated
and usually involves engaging a lawyer.
IV.1.4.4
Technical means of dealing with spam
Technical restrictions
The impact of spam can be limited by using technical means to restrict, for example, the number of
recipients per message, the number of messages per source, and the number of messages per unit of
time.
Blacklists
Blacklists work on the principle that mail can be classified using the server’s reputation as a criterion.
The reputation of a mail server that has recently delivered spam is tarnished in that it can be assumed
that it will send more spam in the future. The server can be identified by its IP address.
Filters that use key words
Key-word filters block messages containing certain key words. They are ineffective because
spammers can easily write their messages to get around the filters.
Profiling technology
Spam consists in sending massive numbers of identical messages. Profiling technology is used to
profile the message content and compare it to a database of contents considered to be spam.
Policy to combat malicious software
A growing variety of “malware” (viruses, Trojan horses, bots, etc.) is being used to install e-mail
servers on infected machines. The aim is to make it easier to propagate spam. Fighting spam also
means hunting down malicious software.
Anti-spam software can help filter and block spam at the level of the e-mail server and thus limit its
spread, but it is not always effective. Legitimate messages do not reach the recipients (concept of false
positives) and genuine spam is allowed through (concept of false negatives).
92
Various aspects of the law regulating new technologies
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents