Cybersecurity guide for developing countries
Directive 1999/93/EC of 13 December 1999 on a European framework for electronic signatures
distinguishes between three types of electronic signature depending on the degree to which the
encryption mechanisms have been integrated and the level of security afforded.
There are various types of electronic signatures. First, a message can simply be “signed’ without the
signature being linked to the content of the message (the basic concept of electronic signature). In this
case, anyone can “detach” the signature from the message and use it in the place of the signature’s
rightful owner. To overcome this shortcoming, a cryptographic function can be used to link the
signature to the content of the message and to validate the sender’s authenticity and the message’s
integrity on reception (concept of advanced electronic signature).
Lastly, the Directive discusses secure electronic signatures, which are based on the security provisions
of Annex II on requirements for certification service providers issuing qualified certificates53.
IV.1.2.4
Right of revocation
The ease with which items can be bought on the internet can incite some consumers to act hastily. The
right of revocation is especially important in this context.
In Switzerland, the right of revocation is regulated in article 9 of the Code of Obligations, paragraph 1
of which sets out the following principle: “If the offeror revokes his offer, and such revocation reaches
the other party prior to […] the offer, […] the offer shall be deemed not to have been made”. The
same principle applies to revocation of acceptance.
Right of revocation and the European Directive
In the European Union, the right of revocation is regulated by Directive 1997/7/EC of 20 May 1997,
which stipulates that for any distance contract the consumer has a period of at least seven working
days in which to withdraw from the contract without penalty and without giving any reason. If the
supplier has failed to fulfil the obligations laid down in article 5, in particular as concerns the
conditions and procedures for exercising the right of withdrawal, the period is three months.
IV.1.2.5
Managing disputes
Those involved in a dispute arising from a validly concluded contract will have to furnish evidence,
whether the contract was concluded electronically or not. It is therefore always advisable to keep a
record of the transaction, such as a copy of the electronic message or a screen print.
The situation in France
In France, article 109 of the Consumer Code does not specify what form the evidence must take in
respect of B2B. E-mails, like paper documents, are therefore admissible. In respect of B2C, however,
written proof is required for transactions in excess of a certain sum. The aim is to protect the average
consumer, who has neither the capacity nor the legal resources to make his case in the event of a
dispute with a commercial firm.
E-mails may, however, be admissible as evidence under the legal texts governing electronic signature.
This means that an e-mail signed electronically will be considered to be valid proof if the above
provisions on electronic signatures are respected.
53 http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2000/l_013/l_01320000119en00120020.pdf
Various aspects of the law regulating new technologies
85
Commented [P5]: I am not sure what is being referred to here.
The EU directive? The Swiss Electronic Signature Act?
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents