P R O LI FE R AT I ON
The end of the INF: horizontal versus vertical proliferation
Proliferation comes in two forms: horizontal and vertical. Horizontal proliferation describes the activities and processes by means of which states without weapons of mass destruction or delivery systems seek to come into possession of such
weapons and thereby acquire new capabilities. Vertical proliferation, by contrast,
denotes the qualitative and quantitative expansion of existing arsenals. There is
an interrelationship between the two forms of proliferation. Pakistan remains a
horizontal proliferation problem, for example in that it procures calibration instruments in Switzerland. These will ultimately be used to arm cruise missiles with
nuclear weapons, i.e. to build up a new capability in the air-based section of the
nuclear triad. At the same time, Pakistan is using existing know-how to optimise
its nuclear weapons and increases their numbers, i.e. is also engaging in vertical
proliferation.
Horizontal nuclear proliferation is banned globally and can therefore not be
the subject of multilateral agreements. Vertical proliferation, on the other hand,
is driven primarily by technological development in the recognised nuclear
weapon states and is the subject of arms control agreements between individual states. Vertical proliferation among the leading nuclear weapon states is a
technology driver and is correspondingly expensive. Disruptive technologies
such as precision navigation by means of inertial sensors or GPS, which nowadays any mobile phone is capable of, were originally developed for military
purposes. It has always been one of the goals of arms control to limit the use of
resources by states for vertical proliferation. There is therefore a high degree of
interaction between arms control and the current status of cutting-edge technology and the global spread of such cutting-edge technology at the time a
treaty is agreed.
The INF Treaty signed in 1987 is a good example of such interaction. It prohibits the deployment of land-based, but not of air-based or sea-based, unmanned
delivery systems with ranges of between 500 and 5,500 kilometres by the armed
forces of the USA and the Soviet Union – or nowadays its legal successor. In 1987,
the two states had a duopoly as far as the quality and quantity of such systems was
concerned, and both states were restricted by the technology of the 1980s to precision navigation systems with an accuracy of around a hundred metres. The term
‘delivery system’ was thus a synonym for ‘nuclear delivery system’, as operations
against tactical targets could be carried out successfully only with nuclear weapons. In the early 1990s, the USA acquired the capability to attack large point targets such as airfields from distances of hundreds of kilometres successfully using
conventionally equipped cruise missiles. By the mid-1990s, it also became possible
72
S I T UAT I O N R E PORT 2 0 1 9 | F I S
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents