A/76/136
A state that invokes a situation of necessity has limited options for taking action.
This ground may be invoked in respect of violations of obligations under international
law only provided there is no other real possibility of taking action to address the
damage caused or threatened, and provided there is no interference with the essential
interests of another state or of the international communityas a whole.
Self-defence
A state targeted by a cyber operation that can be qualified as an armed attack
may invoke its inherent right of self-defence and use force to defend itself. 166 This
right is laid down in article 51 of the UN Charter. This therefore amounts to a
justification for the use of force that would normally be prohibited under article 2(4)
of the UN Charter. 167 For this reason strict conditions are attached to the exercise of
the right of self-defence.
An armed attack is not the same as the use of force within the meaning of
article 2(4) of the UN Charter (see above). In the Nicaragua case, the International
Court of Justice defined an armed attack as the most serious form of the use of force.
This implies that not every use of force constitutes an armed attack.
To determine whether an operation constitutes an armed attack, the scale and
effects of the operation must be considered. 168 International law is ambiguous on the
precise scale and effects an operation must have in order to qualify as an armed attack.
It is clear, however, that an armed attack does not necessarily have to be carried out
by kinetic means. This view is in line with the Nuclear Weapons Advisory Opinion of
the International Court of Justice, in which the Court concludedthat the means by which
an attack is carried out is not the decisive factor in determining whether itconstitutes
an armed attack. The government therefore endorses the finding of the CAVV and the
AIV that ‘a cyber attack that has comparable consequences to an armed attack
(fatalities, damage and destruction) can justify a response with cyber weapons or
conventional weapons (...)’. There is therefore no reason not to qualify a cyberattack
against a computer or information system as an armed attack if the consequences are
comparable to those of an attack with conventional or non- conventional weapons.
At present there is no international consensus on qualifying a cyberattack as an
armed attack if it does not cause fatalities, physical damage or destruction yet
nevertheless has very serious non-material consequences.
The government endorses the position of the International Court of Justice, which
has observed thatan armed attack must have a cross-border character. It should be noted
that not all border incidents involving weapons constitute armed attacks within the
meaning of article 51 of the UN Charter. This depends on the scale and effects of the
incident in question. 169
The burden of proof for justifiable self-defence against an armed attack is a
heavy one. The government shares the conclusion of the CAVV and the AIV that ‘No
form of self-defence whatever may be exercised without adequate proof of the origin or
source of the attack and without convincingproof that a particular state or states or
organised group is responsible for conducting or controllingthe attack.’ 170 States may
therefore use force in self-defence only if the origin of the attack and the identity of
__________________
166
167
168
169
170
64/142
Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, San Francisco, 26 June 1945.
The term ‘prohibition of the use of force’ is explained on page 57.
Case concerning military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v.
United States of America), International Court of Justice (ICJ), 27 June 1986, para. 195.
Ibid.
‘Cyber Warfare’, No 77, AIV/ No 22, CAVV December 2011, p. 22.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents