A/76/136
5.
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter prohibits the threat or use of force against the
territorial integrity or political independence of any State or in any other manner
inconsistent with the purposes of the United Nations. Depending on the facts and
circumstances in each case, conduct by States carried out in cyberspace is capable of
constituting a threat or use of force if the actual or threatened conduct has or would
have the same or similar effects of conduct using kinetic means. The circumstances
in which the threat or use of force is not unlawful under international law are the same
irrespective of whether the conduct is by kinetic or cyber means.
An operation carried out by cyber means may constitute an armed attack giving
6.
rise to the inherent right of individual or collective self-defence, as recognised in
Article 51 of the UN Charter where the scale and effects of the operation are
equivalent to those of an armed attack using kinetic means. Factors in considering the
scale and effects of an attack may include the (actual or anticipated) physical
destruction of property, injury and death. The exercise of the inherent right of selfdefence against an imminent or on-going armed attack whether by kinetic or cyber
means, may itself be by cyber or kinetic means and must always fulfil the
requirements of necessity and proportionality. Whether or not to have recourse to the
exercise of the inherent right of self-defence will always be carefully considered
having regard to all the circumstances.
Article 2(3) and the provisions of Chapter VI of the Charter on the peaceful
7.
settlement of disputes can equally apply in relation to States’ activities in cyberspace.
Thus, in accordance with Article 33(1), States that are party to any cyber-related
international dispute the continuation of which is likely to endanger the maintenance
of international peace and security, shall endeavour to settle such dispute by peaceful
means as described in Article 33 of the Charter: negotiation, enquiry, mediation,
conciliation, arbitration, judicial settlement, resort to regional agencies or
arrangements, or other peaceful means of their own choice.
NON-INTERVENTION & SOVEREIGNTY
8.
Below the threshold of the threat or use of force, the customary international
law rule prohibiting interventions in the domestic affairs of States applies to States’
operations in cyberspace as it does to their other activities. As set out by the
International Court of Justice in its judgment in the Nicaragua case, the purpose of
the rule on non-intervention is to ensure that all States remain free from external
coercive intervention in matters affecting a State’s powers, which are at the heart of
a State’s sovereignty such as the freedom to choose its own political, social, economic
and cultural system. 273
9.
As the UK has noted previously, while the precise boundaries of this rule
continue to be the subject of on-going debate, it provides a clearly established basis
in international law for assessing the legality of State conduct. Thus the use of hostile
cyber operations to manipulate the electoral system in another State to alter the results
of an election, to undermine the stability of another State’s financial system or to
__________________
273
116/142
Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States of
America), Merits, Judgment, ICJ Reports 1986 at para 205: ‘In this respect [the Court] notes that,
in view of the generally accepted formulations, the principle forbids all States or groups of States
to intervene directly or indirectly in internal or external affairs of other States. A prohibited
intervention must accordingly be one bearing on matters in which each State is permitted, by the
principle of State sovereignty to decide freely. One of these is the choice of a political,
economic, social and cultural system, and the formulation of foreign policy. Intervention is
wrongful when it uses methods of coercion in regard to such choices, which must remain free
ones. The element of coercion, which defines, and indeed forms the very essence of, prohibited
intervention, is particularly obvious in the case of an intervention which uses force, either in the
direct form of military action, or in the indirect form of support for subversive or terrorist armed
activities within another State.’
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents