A/76/136
independence of any State. 282 The 2015 GGE report also noted the inherent right of
States to take measures consistent with international law and as recognized in the
Charter. 283 Article 51 of the Charter recognizes “the inherent right of individual or
collective self-defense” in response to an armed attack against a Member State.
1.
Use of force
Cyber activities may in certain circumstances constitute uses of force within
the meaning of Article 2(4) of the UN Charter and customary international law. In
determining whether a cyber activity constitutes a use of force prohibited by
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter and customary international law or an armed attack
sufficient to trigger a State’s inherent right of self-defense, States should consider the
nature and extent of injury or death to persons and the destruction of, or damage to,
property. Although this is necessarily a case-by-case, fact-specific inquiry, cyber
activities that proximately result in death, injury, or significant destruction, or
represent an imminent threat thereof, would likely be viewed as a use of force / armed
attack. If the physical consequences of a cyber activity result in the kind of damage
that dropping a bomb or firing a missile would, that cyber activity should equally be
considered a use of force / armed attack.
Some of the factors States should evaluate in assessing whether an event
constitutes an actual or imminent use of force / armed attack in or through cyberspace
include the context of the event, the actor perpetrating the action (recognizing the
challenge of attribution in cyberspace, including the ability of an attacker to
masquerade as another person/entity or manipulate transmission data to make it
appear as if the cyber activity was launched from a different location or by a different
person), the target and its location, the effects of the cyber activity, and the intent of
the actor (recognizing that intent, like the identity of the attacker, may be difficult to
discern, but that hostile intent may be inferred from the particular circumstances of a
cyber activity), among other factors.
2.
Inherent right of self-defense
A State’s inherent right of self-defense, recognized in Article 51 of the UN
Charter, may in certain circumstances be triggered by cyber activities that amount to
an actual or imminent armed attack. This inherent right of self-defense against an
actual or imminent armed attack in or through cyberspace applies whether the attacker
is a State actor or a non-State actor. There is no requirement that a State defend itself
using the same capabilities with which it is being attacked. States may employ cyber
capabilities that rise to the level of a use of force as a means of self-defense against a
kinetic armed attack (i.e., one that was not launched in or through cyberspace).
Additionally, States may in certain circumstances use kinetic military force in selfdefense against an armed attack in or through cyberspace.
The use of force in self-defense must be limited to what is necessary and
proportionate to address the imminent or actual armed attack in or through
cyberspace. Before resorting to forcible measures in self-defense against an actual or
imminent armed attack in or through cyberspace, States should consider whether
passive cyber defenses or active defenses below the threshold of the use of force
would be sufficient to neutralize the armed attack or imminent threat thereof.
B. Cyber activities and jus in bello
__________________
282
283
21-09670
2015 GGE Report, para. 26.
2015 GGE Report, para. 28(c).
137/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents