A/76/136
make reparations. In principle, the responsible state can only impose countermeasures
if it has first called for the violation(s) to cease and has announced what measures it
is planning to take. Exceptions may be made for cyber operations requiring an
immediate response in order for the injured state to enforce its rights and prevent
further damage. Countermeasures must always be proportional, whatever the
circumstances.
A countermeasure in response to a cyber incident does not necessarily have to
take place in the cyber domain. In accordance with the rules governing state
responsibility, other measures that aim to enforce the responsible state’s compliance
with its international obligations are also permissible. Cyber countermeasures do not
have to directly target the computer system originally used to commit the incident in
question; injured states are permitted to take other measures as long as they are aimed
at the responsible state ceasing its conduct that is in breach of international law. This
means that depending on the specific circumstances, it may be permissible under
international law to use cyber countermeasures to block the computer system abroad
originally used to commit the incident. Likewise, in some cases it may be permissible
to compromise computer systems abroad even if they were not the original source of
the incident.
In addition to countermeasures, the rules governing state responsibility also
provide for special circumstances precluding the wrongfulness of conduct that would
otherwise not be in conformity with the international obligations of the state
concerned. For example, a state may be exempted from complying with such an
obligation if it is the only way for it to safeguard its essential interests from grave and
imminent peril. Therefore the narrowly defined exceptions provided for by the rules
governing state responsibility may also apply in the context of cyber operations. 234
6.3. Due diligence
The principle of due diligence has evolved over a long period of time.
Switzerland views due diligence as part of customary international law and applicable
to cyberspace. The ICJ describes the concept of due diligence as a standard of conduct
meaning “every State’s obligation not to allow knowingly its territory to be used for
acts contrary to the rights of other States.” 235 The doctrine of due diligence reflects
fundamental principles of international law (including state sovereignty, equality,
territorial integrity and non-interference).
The principle of due diligence is also applicable to cyberspace. Consequently, a
state that is or should be aware of cyber incidents that violate the rights of another
state is obliged to take all reasonable measures that are appropriate to stop or
minimise the risks of such incidents. Due diligence is a variable standard and depends
on the capacities and capabilities of a state as well as the particular circumstances of
each case. Territorial states are obliged to use all reasonable means to prevent serious
harm being caused to another state by activities taking place within their territory or
in an area under their effective control. This makes due diligence an obligation of
conduct, not of result. If the aforementioned conditions exist, the state in question is
obliged under international law to close any loopholes immediately and assist in
intercepting and tracing the incident.
__________________
234
235
21-09670
Chapter V, ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts,
August 2001.
Corfu Channel case, ICJ Reports 1949, para. 44. Due diligence is both a general principle of
international law, widely recognised as part of customary international law, and a prominent
legal element in various international agreements where it has been enshrined, defined and
further developed (e.g. environmental law, human rights law, IHL, global health law).
91/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents