ILLEGAL INTELLIGENCE | SITUATION
SI T UAT I O N
Who is spying?
A number of factors lead to illegal intelligence activities in Switzerland. Switzerland is
either the target or merely the setting in which
they take place. Switzerland is a target due to
the high technological standard of Swiss industry and the quality of its research, as well as its
status as a financial centre and a marketplace
for energy and commodities trading. Another
reason is the presence of parts of the UN and
other international bodies based in Switzerland.
There are also various diaspora communities in
Switzerland, which remain a target of activities
by their home countries' intelligence services.
This description alone implies that espionage is a ubiquitous phenomenon. For example,
there are around a dozen states that conduct illegal intelligence against their own nationals in
Switzerland. How far such activities can go is
illustrated by the example of the alleged kidnapping of a Vietnamese citizen in Berlin: he is
said to have been abducted to his home country
in an intelligence operation in order to bring
him to trial there.
All states pursue political, military and economic goals. In order to do so, they deploy intelligence services, which sometimes operate
using illegal methods, i.e. methods prohibited
in the target country. Swiss interests abroad
may also become the target of such measures.
There are therefore good reasons why it is not
possible to come up with a complete list of
the state actors which might at least begin to
develop espionage activities in Switzerland or
76
SI TUATIO N R E P O RT 2018 | F I S
against Swiss interests abroad. However, from
the point of view of counterespionage there are
around half a dozen states meriting particular
attention.
One of these states relies heavily on intelligence officers who are in Switzerland under
diplomatic cover. According to well-founded
suspicions or confirmed intelligence, about a
quarter to a third of the persons in the diplomatic service of this state are intelligence service employees. They can be found in all diplomatic ranks, with the exception of the most
senior. In addition (and this is also true of other
states), intelligence officers are travelling to
Switzerland for operational activities. Switzerland may be the target country of the operation
concerned, or merely be the springboard for activities in another European country.
Who is being spied on?
Illegal intelligence is carried out using a tried
and trusted package of tools and procedures.
Cyber espionage supplements this set; it is supporting conventional illegal intelligence and
vice versa. Information is gradually collected
about a person, for example, in order to be able
to use that person as a source. The person may
be aware of this and may even be remunerated
for it, but this will not necessarily be the case.
The German Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution announced in December 2017 that more than 10,000 recruitment
attempts by Chinese intelligence services had
been identified in a nine-month period. And
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents