A/76/136
The due diligence principle
The due diligence principle holds that states are expected to take account of
other states’ rights when exercising their own sovereignty. The principle is articulated
by the International Court of Justice, for example, in its judgment in the Corfu
Channel Case, 156 in which it held that states have an obligation to act if they are aware
or become aware that their territory is being used for acts contrary to the rights of
another state. It should be noted that not all countries agree that the due diligence
principle constitutes an obligation in its own right under international law. The
Netherlands, however, does regard the principle as an obligation in its own right, the
violation of which may constitute an internationally wrongful act.
In the context of cyberspace, the due diligence principle requires that states take
action in respectof cyber activities:
- carried out by persons in their territory or where use is made of items or
networks thatare in their territory or which they otherwise control;
- that violate a right of another state; and
- whose existence they are, or should be, aware of. 157
To this end a state must take measures which, in the given circumstances, may
be expected of a state acting in a reasonable manner. It is not relevant whether the
cyber activity in question is carried out by a state or non-state actor, or where this actor
is located. If, for example, a cyberattackis carried out against the Netherlands using
servers in another country, the Netherlands may, on the basis of the due diligence
principle, ask the other country to shut down the servers, regardless of whether or not
it has been established that a state is responsible for the cyberattack.
It is generally accepted that the due diligence principle applies only if the state
whose right or rights have been violated suffers sufficiently serious adverse
consequences. The precise threshold dependson the specific circumstances of the case.
It is clear, however, that such adverse consequences do not necessarily have to include
physical damage.
Obligations relating to armed conflict – international humanitarian law
International humanitarian law (IHL) applies to actions in the context of armed
conflict. This includes cyber operations carried out as part of an armed conflict. The
existence of an armed conflict (international or non-international) is thus a
requirement for the application of this specialised areaof law. As early as 2011, the
government observed that applying the rules of international humanitarian law (jus
in bello) to hostilities in cyberspace is ‘technically feasible and legally
necessary’. 158
A key component of IHL is international law on neutrality. Neutrality requires
that states which are not party to an armed conflict refrain from any act from which
__________________
156
157
158
21-09670
Corfu Channel Case; Assessment of Compensation (United Kingdom v. Albania), International
Court of Justice (ICJ), 9 April 1949, para. 22.
Corfu Channel Case; Assessment of Compensation (United Kingdom v. Albania), International
Court of Justice (ICJ), 9 April 1949, para 44. The International Court of Justice concluded that
the constructive knowledge standard of the due diligence principle (within the meaning of
international law) is also met if a state should have known that the activity in question took place
on its territory. Specifically this means that a state has an obligation to do everything feasible.
Precisely what constitutes fulfilment of this requirement in the context of cyberspace is currently
still a matter of debate.
‘Cyber Warfare’, Advisory report no 77, AIV/no. 22, CAVV December 2011, p. 25; government
response to the AIV/CAVV report ‘Cyber Warfare’, 17 January 2012.
59/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents