A/76/136
with territorial integrity is a product of state sovereignty. 217 Accordingly, each state is
obliged to respect the sovereignty of other states. 218 Sovereignty is a binding primary
rule of international law. Violations of sovereignty are therefore considered
internationally wrongful acts which, if attributable to the state itself, give rise to state
responsibility.
State sovereignty is also applicable to cyberspace. 219 Owing to the special
characteristics of cyberspace, which has no clear territorial boundaries, putting the
principle of sovereignty into practice is a particular challenge. One major issue is who
has jurisdiction over or access to digital data. In the cyber context, the key question
is which states have legitimate control over digital data and are authorised to access
that data – which may, depending on the circumstances, be stored on a different
territory or may not be localised geographically. Conversely, in terms of interstate
relations at cybersecurity level, the principle of sovereignty provides wide scope for
protection against cyber operations. For example, state sovereignty protects
information and communication technologies (ICT) infrastructure on a state’s
territory against unauthorised intrusion or material damage. This includes the
computer networks, systems and software supported by the ICT infrastructure,
regardless of whether the infrastructure is private or public.
Switzerland recognises that defining what constitutes a violation of the principle
of sovereignty in cyberspace is particularly challenging and has yet to be clarified
conclusively. It supports considering the following two criteria in such assessments:
first, does the incident violate the state’s territorial integrity and second, does it
constitute interference with or usurpation of an inherently governmental function. A
precise definition of these criteria is a question of interpretation and subject to debate.
The current debate includes among other aspects i) incidents whereby the
functionality of infrastructure or related equipment has been damaged or limited, ii)
cases where data has been altered or deleted, interfering with the fulfilment of
inherently governmental functions such as providing social services, conducting
elections and referendums, or collecting taxes, and iii) situations in which a state has
sought to influence, disrupt or delay democratic decision-making processes in another
state through the coordinated use of legal and illegal methods in cyberspace e.g.
propaganda, disinformation and covert actions by intelligence services. The
assessment of an individual case depends on the nature of the cyber incident and its
repercussions.
3.
Prohibition of intervention
The principle of non-intervention is the corollary of the sovereign equality of
all states (Art. 2 para. 1 UN Charter) and is considered customary international law. 220
In this context, intervention is understood to be the direct or indirect interference by
one sovereign state in the internal or external affairs of another using coercive
measures. It covers those areas where the state has exclusive jurisdiction (known as
domaine réservé). The non-intervention principle protects a state’s ability to shape its
own internal affairs (political, economic, social and cultural systems) as well as its
foreign policy. An infringement of sovereignty and a prohibited intervention are not
the same. The latter must be coercive in nature, i.e. through its intervention a state
seeks to cause another to act (or refrain from acting) in a way it would not
__________________
217
218
219
220
21-09670
Arbitration award in the Island of Palmas case, 1928, p. 838; the Swiss Federal Constitution
recognises state sovereignty under international law on the basis of independence, granting the
state exclusive jurisdiction to make and enforce law within its territory (Art. 2 para. 1).
Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua, ICJ Reports 1986, para. 292.
UN GGE 2013 Report, para. 20; UN GGE 2015 Report, paras. 27 and 28 b).
Friendly Relations Declaration, A/RES/2625 (XXV), 24 October 1970; Military and Paramilitary
Activities in and against Nicaragua, ICJ reports 1986, para. 202.
87/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents