b) Measures of response (1) Retorsion A State may engage in measures of retorsion to counter a cyber operation carried out against it. Retorsions are unfriendly acts directed against the interests of another State without amounting to an infraction of obligations owed to that State under international law. Since retorsions are predominantly rooted in the political sphere, they are not subject to such stringent legal limitations as other types of response such as countermeasures. Measures of retorsion may be adopted to counter (merely) unfriendly cyber operations perpetrated by another State. They may likewise be enacted in reaction to an unlawful cyber operation if more intensive types of response (countermeasures, self-defence) are unavailable for legal reasons (for example, in cases in which counter-measures would be disproportionate) or politically unfeasible. Moreover, they may be adopted as a reaction to an unlawful cyber operation in combination with other types of response, such as countermeasures, as part of a State’s comprehensive, multi-pronged response to malicious cyber activities directed against it. (2) Countermeasures The law of countermeasures allows a State to react, under certain circumstances, to cyberrelated breaches of obligations owed to it by another State by taking measures which for their part infringe upon legal obligations it owes to the other State.61 If certain legal conditions are met, such measures do not constitute wrongful acts under the international law of State responsibility.62 Germany agrees that cyber-related as well as non-cyberrelated breaches of international obligations may be responded to by both cyber and non-cyber countermeasures. 63 As regards the limitations to countermeasures, Germany is of the opinion that, generally, the same conditions apply as in non-cyber-related contexts: In particular, countermeasures may only be adopted against a State which is responsible for an internationally wrongful act in order to induce that State to comply with its obligations arising from its responsibility (in particular cessation of the wrongful act).64 Also, they must 60 61 62 63 64 OJ L 129I, 17 May 2019, p. 13–19, as last amended by Council Decision (CFSP) 2020/1748 of 20 November 2020, OJ L 393, 23 November 2020, p. 19-20. Cf. also Council Decision (CFSP) 2019/797 of 17 May 2019 (note 59), recital 9. Draft Articles on State Responsibility (note 46), part III, chapter II, introductory commentary; Tallinn Manual 2.0 (note 4), rule 20 (with the commentaries). Draft Articles on State Responsibility (note 46), art. 22. Tallinn Manual 2.0 (note 4), rule 20 (with the commentaries). Draft Articles on State Responsibility (note 46), art. 49 para. 1 (with the commentaries); Tallinn Manual 2.0 (note 4), rule 21. 13

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents