4.3
Fundamental policy changes and legislation
The White Paper represents Government policy on Defence and it is not intended that this
Update will re-open fundamentals of defence policy that were settled when the Government
approved the White Paper in 2015. These fundamentals include the fact that Ireland will
continue to maintain its policy of military neutrality. The White Paper also sets out key
principles on capability development that have led to associated progress on rolling multiannual equipment and infrastructure plans. Developments at international level, including
Ireland’s decision to participate in the EU’s Permanent Structured Co-operation Agreement
(PESCO), remain consistent with the approach in the White Paper. As such, changes to
matters of fundamental policy were not considered as part of this Update.
In the context of the White Paper reference to legislative provision for the conduct of fixed
cycle reviews, a concern raised during the Minister’s meeting with the Joint Committee was
whether changes to the concept of Irish neutrality, amending the triple-lock system and
developing a defence industry might be envisaged. In this regard, the White Paper provides
that consideration is to be given to “putting the review process on a statutory footing” but
this commitment simply relates to the question of whether future defence reviews should be
mandated periodically in law, as happens elsewhere. White Paper project number 86 is
focussed on the establishment of the new fixed cycle of defence reviews, and the project
team will consider this issue, but there is no connection between this and issues such as
neutrality, the triple lock and developing our defence industry.
Clearly, however, the development of a regular fixed cycle of reviews presents an opportunity
to foster a wider debate about defence policy in general. Whether, and how, these future
reviews should be used to generate such a debate is an issue that will be considered as part
of the project. Any debate on defence arising from future reviews will, almost inevitably,
feature expressions of contrary views on Ireland’s current policy of military neutrality,
notwithstanding any desire by Government to seek to confine the debate to certain aspects
of defence policy only.
Regarding concern about seeking to develop an Irish defence industry, the position is that
there are no plans to change Ireland’s approach in this regard. Nevertheless, the White Paper
54
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents