gardaí being trained. There is a plan already in place to put some of the new recruits in the Border
region in preparation for a possible hard border. We saw the issue of fisheries last week. That will
become a greater problem or duty for the Defence Forces in the near future if we do not have the
agreement that we intend. The Defence Forces and the Department, when preparing the White Paper,
would not have been aware of Brexit coming down the track. They would not have been focusing as
much on that aspect of security. While I know it has been done, that suggests a need to continually
review the security situation as the Brexit issue develops.
I have raised this issue before so it is more of a comment than a question. The first duty of the military
authorities and the Department is to respect and protect the members of the Defence Forces and to
enhance morale. There are a number of issues and events that have happened in recent years which
are contributing to lowering that morale. I have not heard any problem with regard to protection of
soldiers. I think they are happy with the protection. Respect of soldiers has been brought into question
by the lack of proper wages and proper health and safety standards in the past.
Brendan Smith, Chairman
I will take Senator O'Sullivan. We are running into time constraints again and have the select
committee soon.
Senator Ned O'Sullivan
I will keep it very tight. I welcome the Minister of State and his officials. It is good that the Minister of
State wanted to engage with us. Having said that, maybe I was ill-prepared for the meeting or my
expectations were different, but I am disappointed and underwhelmed by what the Minister of State
has to say to us. He says he wants to listen to our views but at the same time, for anyone looking in
from outside, White Papers and Green Papers are like dancing on the head of a pin. People want to
know where the beef is and what the Minister of State's vision is for the Defence Forces. We cannot
treat White Papers and Green Papers as an ongoing circle of bureaucracy.
The Defence Forces are highly respected and held in high regard by the public, and rightly so. As
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan said, their work as peacekeepers in the UN is exemplary and something of
which we are all very proud. We are also proud of the profile the Army has in many State functions. I
particularly welcomed its activities in schools during the 1916 centenary. It is also lovely to see the
Army band in communities. When there are weather and climate crises, the Army plays a role and this
is also appreciated. These are the upsides as far as I can see but there are some serious downsides.
The Minister of State said the White Paper is not the place to speak about Army pay or all of the
resignations and buy-outs from the Army. Perhaps we will have another day for that. Is the Minister
of State concerned about morale in the Defence Forces? The morale of any force, be it the Garda,
Army or Naval Service, is important. It is important for us as committee members to know whether
the Minister of State is happy with the state of morale in our Defence Forces.
Insofar as the White Paper deals with it, will the Minister give us an update on where we are with
Army property? There has been a lot of speculation that some of our big barracks, such as Cathal
Brugha Barracks, will be used for housing. I am not saying it is good or bad; I would just like to know
the future of Army property in rural towns, such as Listowel, where we used to have slua halls and
FCA property. What is the future for this type of property, as the Minister of State sees it?
Does the Minister of State have plans to inject new life into the RDF? Recently in the Seanad I
mentioned to him that I thought the FCA was an exemplary force that gave a lot of young people in
Ireland training in life skills, a sense of patriotism and something useful. The Army has a very low
profile in the country. This is not necessarily a bad thing. I am not looking for militarisation. The Army
95
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents