considering the structure and processes for the future conduct of defence reviews and, in doing so,
will draw from the experience gained in carrying out the current update. The project team has
undertaken a broad-ranging study, including academic review and international comparisons, in order
to identify the key elements that could shape the conduct of future defence reviews. When finalised,
proposals in this regard will be brought to the Government for approval. Before that happens,
however, it is the Government's stated intention in the White Paper to engage in a process of all-party
consultation on the overall approach. This committee is an ideal forum to address that commitment.
There are a number of key elements being considered as part of the ongoing project and, subject to
the committee's perspective, it is on the following questions, in particular, that I would appreciate
views: whether legislative provision should be made for the conduct of fixed-cycle reviews; the extent
to which the reviews should differ – for example, what should distinguish an update from a strategic
defence review; the level and breadth of consultation for each; the frequency and timing of reviews;
and whether, regardless of these reviews, there is a case for a continuing approach that includes
provision for further White Papers and, if so, when, within the new cycle of reviews.
Having outlined the purpose of my seeking this engagement with the joint committee, and once again
emphasising that my approach today is simply to take account of what committee members have to
say, I look forward to listening to and considering their views on these important matters related to
the White Paper on Defence.
Brendan Smith, Chairman
I thank the Minister of State for his detailed presentation on the work that is ongoing and for the
update on the White Paper.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan
I acknowledge the engagement with the committee. It is positive that we are meeting rather often on
these matters.
The Minister of State mentioned a high-level civil-military steering group. Who exactly are the
members of that group?
The Minister of State also referred to whether legislative provision should be made for the conduct of
fixed-cycle reviews. What kinds of changes does he envisage that would require such provision? I am
putting this in the context of a report I have been quoting recently and on which the Minister of State's
MEP colleagues engaged at EU level, namely, Ireland and the EU: Defending our Common European
Home. It contains some alarming comments - for example, on redefining the concept of Irish
neutrality, amending our triple-lock system and developing our defence industry. It does not sit easily
that such comments are coming from some MEPs when we are committed to Ireland's neutrality here.
It was great that the Minister of State received so many submissions. Many came from civil society. I
am wondering about further engagement because, with defence, it is civil society that is most effective
when anything goes wrong.
There is an increase in military expenditure. Does the Minister of State envisage further increases?
There are concerns in this regard. I asked the Minister of State before about the multi-role vessel that
was possibly being purchased.
I thank the Minister of State for the letter he sent me following up on my question on training. He
outlined in it some of the training that takes place. I acknowledge the great work our peacekeeping
forces do when on UN-mandated missions. My question was on interrogation training. The Minister
89
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents