Consultation with civil society is regarded as being an important part of engendering a wider
debate, than normally takes place, about defence issues across society and with stakeholders.
The Department of Defence will look at ways to enhance and shape such consultation as part
of the process of conducting future defence reviews. In light of their national importance,
the Government’s view is that defence matters should ideally attract all party support and
there is an acknowledgement in the White Paper of the strong tradition within the chambers
of the Oireachtas of support for national interest defence issues. In this spirit, the White
Paper committed to a process of all-party consultation to seek to put proposals for defence
reviews in place on a consensual basis, and subject to appropriate refinement through these
consultations, consideration is to be given in due course to putting the review process on a
statutory footing. The Minister’s meeting with the Joint Committee embraced the process of
all party consultation outlined in the White Paper and the Government is committed to
ensuring that any process of consultation in the context of future reviews will continue to
include engagement with members of the Oireachtas.
The extent of consultation that is to be carried out at each review cycle will be addressed as
part of the White Paper project (no. 86) that is focussed on the establishment of the new fixed
cycle defence reviews. The observations of the Committee on the importance of consultation
will feed into the work of the project team. The level of consultation that will be undertaken
for future reviews will depend on a number of factors, including decisions concerned with
other aspects of the review cycles, such as the time-periods covered and the focus of future
reviews. From international comparison carried out to date as part of the project, it is
apparent that many countries engage in wide-ranging consultation when conducting defence
reviews. In both New Zealand and Canada, this includes consultation with the general public
on a large scale, with town hall style meetings, as well as interaction with defence experts and
analysts. This level of consultation tends to be during the development of cornerstone policy
documents, in the same way that the 2013 Green Paper sought to engage the public during
the development of the 2015 White Paper. At the other end of the spectrum, some countries
do not engage in any form of express public consultation on defence policy development.
53
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents