significant communication between my Department, the British Ministry of Defence, our Defence
Forces and the British Armed Forces. The memorandum of understanding that was signed between
their Minister, Michael Fallon, and our then Minister, Deputy Simon Coveney, will stand. Brexit has no
impact on that.
Deputy Jack Chambers
The last question I asked was about the EU Partnership for Peace in-depth evaluation of Ireland's
military capability, which is ongoing. Will the Minister of State publish it?
Deputy Paul Kehoe
I will come back to the Deputy on that.
Deputy Aengus Ó Snodaigh
Since the White Paper was published, I have engaged through a number of parliamentary questions. I
find the way the White Paper is laid out strange. There is no harm in it. If one reads through it, one
will just about find what the tasks and targets are. The Minister of State mentioned 95. We were
originally told it was 88. There is no list within the White Paper itself so sometimes it is very difficult
to judge. Most other documents of that scale have the target, purpose and timeframe in which it is
hoped that goals will be achieved at the end. I know the Minister of State has supplied some of that
material to me since. It makes it difficult for people looking in to gauge whether the Minister of State,
Department or military authorities are successful in achieving what has been set out. It is quite obvious
that we are not achieving some goals.
There is a chapter on retention of soldiers. Recruitment is being achieved. We have seen people being
recruited and cadets being sworn in recently. I congratulate them. There is a dilemma that we have
discussed in the committee, of recruitment and retention and the problems that creates for military
authorities while trying to plan for the future. If one has a cohort of older, more experienced soldiers
leaving and newer recruits, it makes it difficult to plan major events, overseas operations, fisheries
protection operations or for whatever skills are then missing. In recent years, air ambulances have not
been able to provide the full cover that is expected of the Defence Forces by the public. It is conditional
on their availability but the public has, or at least had, a view that the Defence Forces are available as
an aid to the civil power. The military authorities can only do that if they have the personnel and
equipment required. We have seen a number of occasions where they have been constrained or
where it has created difficulties relating to a lack of soldiers or equipment.
An issue I have with regard to the role of the Defence Forces is that there should be greater
concentration on preparing the Defence Forces for more operations abroad, such as disaster relief
and infrastructural works. They have shown in Ireland that they can do that. They have been quite
good if a bridge goes down, for example.
The change to a two brigade system meant the loss of one of the engineering units and a lack of
equipment for disaster and humanitarian relief. I have a different view to most recent Governments,
which seem to have embraced the EU battlegroup role for the Irish Defence Forces rather than
peacekeeping and helping in disaster zones around the country.
My criticism of the review is that the White Paper should be made more accessible. The Minister of
State set out the 95 targets or tasks so that when the cyclical reviews come up, it is easier for people
on the outside to comment and say that they want there to be more focus on certain matters. Brexit
has really changed much of what was set out in the White Paper. The Minister of State is here this
week and it is maybe a pity that it is not next month, since we might have some surety about it then.
That will impact on the call on the Defence Forces relating to Border duties. There are stories about
94
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents