Constitution and the Basis of Defense Policy
Section
2
❶
Constitution and the Basis of Defense Policy
Constitution and the Right of Self-Defense
●
inherent right of self-defense as a sovereign state. Thus, the
Japanese Government interprets this as a constitutional right
to possess the minimum armed forces needed to exercise that
right. Therefore, Japan, under the Constitution, maintains
the Self-Defense Forces (SDF) as an armed organization,
holding its exclusively defense-oriented policy as its basic
strategy of defense, and continues to keep it equipped and
ready for operations.
The Government’s View on Article 9 of the Constitution
1 Permitted Self-Defense Capability
Under the Constitution, Japan is permitted to possess the
required minimum self-defense capability. The specific limit
is subject to change according to the prevailing international
situation, the level of military technologies, and various other
factors, and it is discussed and decided through annual budget
and other deliberations by the Diet on behalf of the people.
Whether such capability constitutes a “war potential” that is
prohibited by Article 9, Paragraph 2 of the Constitution must
be considered within the context of Japan’s overall military
strength. Therefore, whether the SDF should be allowed
to possess certain armaments depends on whether such
possession would cause its total military strength to exceed
the constitutional limit.
The possession of armaments deemed to be offensive
weapons designed to be used only for the mass destruction
of another country is not permissible under any circumstance
as it would, by definition, exceed the minimum necessary
level. For example, the SDF is not allowed to possess
intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBM), long-range
strategic bombers, or attack aircraft carriers.
2 Measures for Self-Defense Permitted under Article
9 of the Constitution
In the past, the Government had interpreted Article 9 of
the Constitution to mean that armed force could be used to
exercise the right of self-defense only when the following
three conditions (Three Conditions for “Use of Force”) were
met: (1) When there is an imminent and illegitimate act of
aggression against Japan; (2) When there are no appropriate
means to deal with such aggression other than by resorting to
●
the right of self-defense; and (3) When the use of armed force
is confined to be the minimum necessary level. However, it
has been concluded in the Cabinet’s decision made on July
1, 2014, “Development of Seamless Security Legislation to
Ensure Japan’s Survival and Protect its People,” that “the
use of force” should be interpreted to be permitted under the
Constitution as measures for self-defense when the following
“Three New Conditions” are met: (1) When an armed attack
against Japan has occurred, or when an armed attack against
a foreign country that is in a close relationship with Japan
occurs and as a result threatens Japan’s survival and poses
a clear danger to fundamentally overturn people’s right to
life, liberty and pursuit of happiness; (2) When there is no
appropriate means available to repel the attack and ensure
Japan’s survival and protect its people; (3) Use of force to the
minimum extent necessary. The following is the interpretation
of the measures for self-defense permitted under Article 9
of the Constitution defined in the abovementioned Cabinet
decision.
The language of Article 9 of the Constitution appears
to prohibit “use of force” in international relations in all
forms. However, when considered in light of “the right (of
the people) to live in peace” as recognized in the Preamble
of the Constitution and the purpose of Article 13 of the
Constitution which stipulates, “their (all the people’s) right
to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” shall be the
supreme consideration in governmental affairs, Article 9 of
the Constitution cannot possibly be interpreted to prohibit
Japan from taking measures of self-defense necessary to
maintain its peace and security and to ensure its survival.
Such measures for self-defense are permitted only when they
are inevitable for dealing with imminent unlawful situations
where the people’s right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of
Defense of Japan
200
Chapter
1
Basic Concepts of Japan’s Security and Defense
Since the end of World War II, Japan made a decision not
to repeat the ravages of war and has worked hard to build
a peace-loving nation. The Japanese people desire lasting
peace, and the principle of pacifism is enshrined in the
Constitution, Article 9 of which prescribes the renunciation
of war, the prohibition of war potential, and the denial of the
right of belligerency of the state. Of course, since Japan is
an independent nation, these provisions do not deny Japan’s
❷
Section 2
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents