China Section 2
36
37
exercises since the end of the Cold War, the Tsentr-2019
exercise in 2019, Maneuvers “Kavkaz 2020” in 2020, and
Zapad/Interaction-2021 in 2021. Additionally, the two
countries have held the large-scale bilateral naval exercise
“Joint Sea” since 2012. The annual exercise for 2016 took
place in the South China Sea for the first time, and that for
2017 was held in the Baltic Sea and Sea of Okhotsk for the
first time. In October 2021, a group of vessels, including a
Renhai-class destroyer, participated in the exercise, which
was conducted in the Sea of Japan. Furthermore, China
and Russia continued this by conducting their first joint
navigation around Japan by a total of 10 vessels from both
countries. In 2016 and 2017, the two countries held the
“Aerospace Security” missile defense computer-simulated
exercise. Furthermore, China has held the counterterrorism
joint exercise “Peace Mission” between China and
Russia or among the member countries of the Shanghai
Cooperation Organization (SCO), established in June 2001
including Russia. China likely regards these exchanges
as an opportunity to learn about how to operate Russianmade weapons and the operational doctrine of the Russian
Armed Forces, which have combat experiences.
In addition, moves indicating deepened China-Russia
relations have been confirmed in recent years. In the two
countries’ “first joint strategic flight” of bombers in July
2019, their bombers joined in the Sea of Japan and flew to
the East China Sea. In September 2019, China and Russia
signed a series of documents on cooperation in the military
and military technologies.37 Similar trends continued in
2020. In December that year, Russian Defense Minister
Sergey Shoigu and Chinese Defense Minister Wei Fenghe
held a video teleconference and signed a protocol on the
extension of the intergovernmental agreement on mutual
notifications of ballistic missile and carrier rocket launches
for 10 years. In the same month, Russian and Chinese
bombers conducted a long-distance joint flight from the
Sea of Japan to the East China Sea and the Pacific Ocean.
Bombers from both countries also conducted a longdistance joint flight in November 2021. Comparing the
previous two joint flights by Chinese and Russian aircraft,
diversification of the flight pattern was seen in 2021,
including that it was conceivable that the aircraft mutually
passed through Chinese and Russian airspace and then
advanced to the Sea of Japan before reaching the vicinity
of Japan. Bombers from both countries further conducted
Chapter
3
Defense Policies of Countries
various points. They affirmed their opposition to Taiwan
independence and further NATO expansion, concern over
the establishment of AUKUS, and calls for the withdrawal
of the U.S. plan to deploy shorter- and intermediate-range
ground-based missiles in the Asia-Pacific region and in
Europe. Furthermore, China and Russia confirmed that
“there are no ‘forbidden’ areas of cooperation” between
the two countries and that they would continue to maintain
high-level mutual visits in a close manner, effectively deal
with external interference and regional security threats,
and defend global strategic stability. They also emphasized
that they would conduct coordination and cooperation, and
the need to fulfill responsibilities of major powers.
Since Russia began its aggression against Ukraine
on February 24, 2022, China has taken the position that
it is not concerned with Russia’s plans for aggression.
However, China does not blame Russia, and insists that
Russia’s actions are caused by the “Cold War mentality” of
the NATO member countries including the United States,
and that it understands Russia’s reasonable concerns on
security issues. Furthermore, China emphasizes that both
China and Russia have made it clear that the so-called
“provision of military assistance to Russia by the Chinese
side” is complete disinformation.
On the military front, since the 1990s, China has
purchased modern weapons from Russia, including fighters,
destroyers, and submarines. Russia is currently the largest
supplier of weapons to China.36 Although China-Russia
arms transactions in value in recent years have been lower
than in some past period, China has apparently continued to
indicate its strong interests in importing advanced Russian
defense equipment and in joint equipment development
with Russia. For example, China has introduced what are
believed to be the latest fourth generation Su-35 fighters
and the S-400 surface-to-air missile system from Russia.
China has been reported as the first country to import the
Russian S-400 missile system. It is also suggested that
Russia has concerns about competing with China in arms
exports taking into consideration China’s improvement of
technological power.
Military exchanges between China and Russia take
place in such forms as routine mutual visits by senior
military officers and bilateral and multilateral exercises.
For example, China participated in the Vostok 2018
exercise, viewed as one of the largest Russian military
According to “Arms Transfers Database,” SIPRI.
According to the Russian military newspaper Krasnaya Zvezda (the “Red Star”) on September 6, 2019.
DEFENSE WHITE PAPER
58
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents