Part I
Security Environment Surrounding Japan
Column
The developments of the military cooperation between Russia and China:
The repercussions of “strategic coordination”
In recent years, Russia and China have been increasing
cooperation in the military sector. In the past, there was tension
between the Soviet Union and China, including militarily, with
the two countries experiencing, among other incidents, the
Sino-Soviet border conflict in 1969. Since the 1980s, the two
countries have been gradually improving relations. As a catalyst
event for the normalization of relations in May 1989, in what had
been a pending issue in the relations between the two countries,
the work of demarcating borders was resumed (demarcated
conclusively in 2008). In parallel with such work, efforts including
the reduction of forces in border regions in accordance with
agreements have been implemented to establish the foundation
of proximity between the countries that can be seen today.
In 2003 Russia and China conducted their first joint counterterrorism military exercise “Cooperation 2003” of the Shanghai
Cooperation Organization (SCO), which was established with the
framework for border demarcation, with Russia incorporating
countries of the former Soviet Union, Central Asian countries, and
China as the parent body. In 2005 the two countries renamed the
exercise “Peace Mission” and have been implementing the joint
counter-terrorism military exercise. The two countries have also
been conducting “Joint Sea” joint naval exercises since 2012.
From the outset, there have been years where “Peace Mission”
exercises were implemented together with Central Asian
countries, and years where the exercises were implemented
by only China and Russia. In recent years, India and Pakistan,
which have become new SCO member countries, have also been
participating, therefore it can be considered that a focus of the
exercises is the enhancement of military capabilities of Central
Asian countries, keeping in mind the strengthening of military
ties between Eurasian countries, centering on Russia and China,
and the situation in Afghanistan.
While Joint Sea activities have been identified as “inwardfacing” to allow Russia and China to ascertain the other’s naval
capabilities, the activities may also be considered “outward
facing,” demonstrating the cooperation and interests of each
to third countries in waters where their respective interests are
significant, with the exercises conducted not only in the Sea of
Japan, East China Sea, Yellow Sea and other waters of major
activity for both the Russian Pacific Fleet and People’s Liberation
Army Navy, the main participating units in the exercises, but also
in the Mediterranean Sea in 2015, South China Sea in 2016, and
Chapter
3
Defense Policies of Countries
115
DEFENSE OF JAPAN 2022
Baltic Sea in 2017.
In recent years, such cooperation between Russia and
China on the military front has become more conspicuous,
as if to promote it as “strategic coordination” movements. For
example, between 2018 and 2020, the People’s Liberation Army
participated in Russia’s internal yearly strategic command and
staff exercise, and in August 2021, the Armed Forces of the
Russian Federation participated in ZAPAD/INTERACTION-2021
bilateral strategic exercise within China for the first time. In
addition, since 2019, Russia and China have conducted joint
bomber flights in airspace over the Sea of Japan, East China
Sea, and Pacific Ocean. In October 2021, the two countries
implemented joint navigations for the first time by 10 naval
vessels, mainly those vessels participating in the aforementioned
“Joint Sea” exercises, which involved orbiting Japan. In November
of the same year, joint flights were conducted with bombers from
Russia and China, with Russian planes passing through Chinese
airspace and Chinese planes passing though Russian airspace,
each for the first time. The bombers advanced directly toward the
Sea of Japan, and from the Sea of Japan to the East China Sea
and the Pacific Ocean.
Appearing to substantiate the view that these actions are a
strengthening of “strategic coordination,” in an online conference
between the defense ministers of Russia and China in November
2021, the Russian side asserted that the increased frequency
of activity by U.S. strategic bombers in the airspace adjacent
to Russia’s is a threat not only for Russia but also for China.
Alongside this, it was announced that the militaries of the two
countries have agreed to strengthen their partnership relating
to a “Joint Patrol,” which is believed to refer to bilateral strategic
exercises, as well as the aforementioned joint flights and joint
navigation. Furthermore, in January 2022 Russia and China
announced that they had conducted joint naval training including
Iran in the Arabian Sea. In May, three months into Russia’s
aggression against Ukraine, the fourth joint flight with bombers
from Russia and China was conducted in the skies over the Sea
of Japan, the East China Sea, and the Pacific on the day of the
Japan–US–Australia–India leaders’ summit in Tokyo. These
moves show that the joint military activity between Russia and
China is gradually expanding and shifting its focus from initial
bilateral confidence-building in inner Eurasia to widely appealing
their bilateral cooperation to the international community
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents