A/76/136
Due diligence applies in particular to actions by private individuals that violate
the rights of other states (e.g. hackers) and cannot be (clearly) attributed to the state
in accordance with the rules of attribution (see section 6.1). If the aforementioned
conditions exist and the state in question fails to fulfil due diligence requirements, the
injured state may take countermeasures in accordance with the rules governing state
responsibility in order to induce the responsible state to meet its obligations. Possible
countermeasures outlined above may be taken both outside and inside the cyber
domain. The responsible state may also be required to make reparations. 236
7.
Human rights
Human rights are a cornerstone of international law. They are enshrined in a
number of treaties including the UN Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)
and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). Fundamental human rights
are also part of customary international law and can in part be categorised as jus
cogens. Today, state obligations in respect of human rights have several dimensions.
States must refrain from interfering with human rights (obligation to respect), protect
individuals and groups against any such interference by third parties (obligation to
protect) and take positive action to facilitate the enjoyment of basic human rights
(obligation to fulfil).
Human rights also apply in the digital space and are a key pillar in the
international regulatory framework for digitalisation. Individuals therefore have the
same rights in the digital space as they do in physical space. This also applies to state
security activities in cyberspace i.e. part of the digital space. Human rights obligations
are equally binding upon states operating in cyberspace as in physical space. This also
applies when the cyber operation in question is being carried out extraterritorially, to
the extent that the States exercise their sovereign authority in doing so. If a cyberrelated activity results in a violation of human rights, the victim will in principle have
recourse to the enforcement mechanisms of the applicable domestic and international
treaties in the same way as if the violation had been committed in physical space.
Human rights monitoring bodies and tribunals can expand the scope and applicability
of human rights in their practice.
A number of specific human rights may be particularly affected by cyber-related
activities. An individual’s right of access to information, right to privacy, or freedom
of expression for example, could be restricted because of cyber operations or other
cyber-related measures.
A state must be able to justify restricting these or other human rights in
cyberspace based on the same rules that apply in physical space. In principle, any act
of state interference requires an adequate legal basis. The state must also be able to
demonstrate that in the balance of interests its actions are appropriate, necessary and
reasonable in order to meet a legitimate objective.
Switzerland considers the applicability of human rights to cyberspace to be an
unequivocal principle. However, new questions may arise when considering how this
applies in individual cases. For example, if cyber-related activities are used to block
access to social media, the question of freedom of expression may need to be
clarified – at what point can this legally protected right be interfered with? Can the
individual continue to exercise this right through alternative communication
channels? To what extent are private actors also bound by human rights obligations?
Human rights bodies need to develop their work in this field in order to ensure the
application of human rights in cyberspace.
__________________
236
92/142
Art. 31, ILC Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts,
August 2001.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents