A/76/136
cyberattack. A countermeasure is different to the practice of retorsion in that it would
normally be contrary to international law. Forthis reason, countermeasures are subject
to strict conditions, including the requirement that the injured state invoke the other
state’s responsibility. This involves the injured state establishing a violation of an
obligation under international law that applies between the injured state and the
responsible state, and requires that the cyber operation can be attributed to the
responsible state. In addition, the injured state must in principle notify the other state
of its intention to take countermeasures. However, if immediate action is required in
order to enforce the rights of the injured state and prevent further damage, such
notification may be dispensed with. Furthermore, countermeasures must be temporary
and proportionate, they may not violate any fundamental human rights, and they may
not amount to the threat or use of force.
Necessity
Necessity is a ground justifying an act which, under certain strict conditions,
offers justification for an act that would otherwise be deemed internationally
wrongful, such as deploying offensive cybercapabilities against another state. A state
may invoke necessity if the following conditions are met:
- there is an immediate and serious threat to an essential interest of the state
concerned;
- there is no other way to respond to this threat other than to temporarily suspend
compliance with one or more of the state’s obligations under international law;
- the temporary non-compliance does not constitute a serious interference with the
essential interests of another state towards which the obligation under
international law exists or of the international community, and invocation of
necessity in regard to this specific obligation is permitted under international
law; 165
- the state itself has not contributed to the situation of necessity.
Thus, the ground of necessity may be invoked only in exceptional cases where
not only are there potentially very serious consequences, but there is also an essential
interest at stake for the state under threat. What constitutes an ‘essential interest’ is
open to interpretation in practice, but in the government’s view services such as the
electricity grid, water supply and the banking system certainly fall into this category.
As regards the ‘very serious consequences’ required for establishing the
existence of a situation of necessity, it should be noted that the damage does not
already have to have taken place, but it must be imminent and objectively verifiable.
There is no established standard on the degree to whichthe damage in question can be
deemed sufficiently serious to justify invoking the ground of necessity. This must be
determined on a case-by-case basis. Damage that merely amounts to an impediment
or inconvenience is not sufficient. The damage caused or threatened does not
necessarily have to be physical: situations in which virtually the entire internet is
rendered inaccessible or where there are severe shocks to the financial markets could
be classified as circumstances in which invoking necessity may be justified. Equally,
establishing the existence of a situation of necessity does not require a state to
determine the precise origin of the damage or whether another state can be held
responsible for it. This ground for justification is primarily aimedat giving a state the
opportunity to protect its own interests and minimise the damage it suffers.
__________________
165
21-09670
In the case of some obligations under international law, invoking a ground justifying an act in
violation of the obligation is not permitted. These are known as the peremptory norms of
international law, such as the prohibition of genocide.
63/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents