Chapter 5 Violation of cyberspace poses a risk | CSAN 2021
Boosting resilience against system failure and misuse of elements
of the technical layer is a limited possibility for individual states
and organisations. One reason is that cyberspace is an ecosystem
consisting of many components and in which many parties play a
role. CSAN 2020 explained that there are various reasons why
cyberspace security does not come about automatically. The risks to
the entire cyberspace and their impact on society are also difficult
to fathom. However, the design of the Internet does take into
account vulnerabilities such as component failures. This ensures a
high degree of redundancy and flexibility in the infrastructure. The
design of the protocols also takes account of the failure of parts of
the infrastructure.
Exploitation of vulnerabilities in software and hardware
worries
The exploitation of (zero day) vulnerabilities in widely used
software or hardware causes concern because of the scale of the
impact. For example, since the beginning of 2021, an actor has
been exploiting (then unknown) vulnerabilities in Microsoft
Exchange Server. These vulnerabilities potentially affected
hundreds of thousands of organisations worldwide. When
Microsoft announced the vulnerabilities on 02 March 2021,
simultaneously with patches to remedy them, other actors also
exploited these vulnerabilities at organisations that had not
installed the patches (on time) (see Core CSAN). The NCSC stated
that the consequences of the vulnerabilities in Microsoft Exchange
Server were significant for Dutch organisations and companies.
The NCSC found that as a result of these vulnerabilities, data was
stolen, malware was installed, backdoors were built in and
mailboxes were offered for sale on the black market. Malicious
parties could possibly also have penetrated other systems via the
vulnerabilities in Microsoft Exchange server. On 20 April 2021,
Pulse Secure warned of an actively attacked zero day vulnerability in
the company's VPN software that allowed remote attackers to take
over vulnerable VPN servers. A security update was not yet available
and, according to Pulse Secure, the security hole posed a very great
risk to organisations. However, a workaround was published, as
well as a tool that allowed customers to check whether their VPN
server had been compromised. Pulse Secure is used worldwide and
the vulnerability makes many organisations vulnerable to
exploitation by malicious parties.
Misuse of global ICT supply chains is common
As far as the process layer is concerned, the way organisations and
people use cyberspace, it is misuse of global ICT supply chains that
is of particular concern. The last three CSANs have highlighted the
threat posed by an attack on ICT supply chains, termed ‘chains’ for
convenience. Such an attack targets one or more vulnerabilities in
chains rather than a specific process or organisation. An actor can
affect many processes or organisations through weaknesses in
chains. Conversely, these are intertwined with numerous chains
and are therefore vulnerable to attacks through and within each of
these chains. Those connections and thus vulnerabilities can be
far-reaching (see Figure 2). Even in the highly simplified
representation below, an actor who wants to attack a process of a
large organisation can try to do so via the processes of four other
organisations. For example, an attacker could try to attack a cloud
provider via a monitoring tool provider and then a large
organisation via that provider. Large-scale system failure within or
of chains is also conceivable. A small number of tech companies
have a dominant market position for certain types of service. The
chance of system failure may not be very high, but if there is a
failure, it will affect the digital processes of many states and
organisations.
Figure 2: Simplified visualisation of an ICT supply chain
Supplier development
environment
Supplies to
Supplier
monitoring tools
Supplies to
Cybersecurity
company
Supplies to
Large
organisation
Supplies to
Supplies to
Supplies to
Cloudprovider
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents