Core CSAN: Cyber Attacks Impair Society’s Central Nervous System | CSAN 2021
In chapter 4, the cybercrime threat is further explained by the
police. Here, the focus is on the use of ransomware as the final
element of a comprehensive cybercrime process. The geopolitical
motives behind the activities of state actors are further explained in
chapter 6.
Cybercriminals can impair national security
Cybercriminals can cause extensive damage to digital processes
through their attacks. A number of cybercrime groups now have
capabilities on par with those of state actors. This implies that their
attacks may have a similar impact as those of state actors. Although
cybercriminals are mainly focused on making money and do not
deliberately set out to disrupt society, their attacks can cause so
much damage that national security interests are affected. This may
be the case, for example, when they make critical processes
inaccessible by means of ransomware.
Although targeted attacks on critical processes have not yet been
observed in the Netherlands, they do occur abroad. The CSAN 2020
reported ransomware attacks on industrial control systems (ICS)
that are part of the drinking water and energy supply infrastructure,
for example. In the past year, critical processes in the electricity,
water, oil & gas, chemical, food, transport and healthcare sectors
worldwide were again targeted by criminal groups through cyber
attacks. Various reports have found that the resilience in critical
processes in the Netherlands is sometimes inadequate. The Cyber
Security Council has concluded that even in organisations that are
part of critical processes, basic ICT and security hygiene is
frequently inadequate, as a result of which basic threats to their
processes cannot be countered or detected. In addition, a report by
the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate shows that
Waternet, which supplies drinking water to Amsterdam and the
surrounding area, is insufficiently in control of its cybersecurity. As
a result, there is an increased risk of a cyber incident with possible
consequences for the quality and/or continuity of the drinking
water supply. Lastly, research conducted following a hack at a water
supply company in the United States shows that many ICSs in the
Netherlands are easily accessible. Using relatively simple Google
searches, the researchers found many systems that had no or hardly
any cybersecurity.
In addition to the fact that cybercriminals (also) target critical
processes, the relationships they maintain with state actors are a
source of concern. For example, cybercrime groups are hired by the
national government of the country in which they are based to
carry out cyber attacks (hackers-for-hire). Or cybercrime groups are
tolerated by the state and pressured to carry out attacks for hire.
Sometimes this involves appealing to their ‘patriotism’. Lastly,
there are examples of criminal hackers who (also) work for
government agencies that have a public task in fighting
cybercrime.
Due to the possible impact on national security, this CSAN pays
more attention to cybercriminals than in previous years. Today’s
cybercrime ecosystem is a mature system. It is a system where
actors are supported by facilitators who offer technical, financial
and legal services for cyber attacks. Professional and customerfriendly service providers also bring new actors onto the scene:
criminals engaged in ‘traditional’ types of crime (such as drug
dealers) branch out into cyber attacks, such as phishing. In the
future, cyber attacks by criminals also engaging in all kinds of other
crime may lead to the addition of a physical component to
cybercrime, such as the threat or use of force after a phishing or
ransomware attack, or physical consequences due to the
inaccessibility of processes.
Chapter 4 explains the cybercrime threat in more detail, focusing
on the use of ransomware.
Attacks breach security of cyberspace
All our digital processes are strongly interlinked with and
dependent on the global cyberspace. Digital processes, such as
those of providers of critical infrastructure, but also those of large
and small organisations and citizens, use the services and products
of globally operating companies. Examples include products
enabling remote working, managing and sending emails and
storing and processing information with a cloud provider. In
addition, digital processes are interlinked with and dependent on
the technical infrastructure of the internet, including undersea
cables. This interwovenness has brought many benefits and
continues to offer opportunities, but also poses a risk. What if, in
today’s tense geopolitical context, state actors were to tap undersea
communications cables for intelligence gathering or manipulate
internet protocols on a massive scale? What if – in times of conflict
– state actors sabotaged those cables? What if malicious parties
manipulated or sabotaged digital processes or products of global
companies? What if the services of one of the three largest global
cloud providers became unavailable for a short or long period due
to a technical failure?
Such types of abuse or outages that breach (the security of )
cyberspace have a major impact on the functioning of all digital
processes. They make sensitive or vulnerable personal, economic
or political information accessible to malicious parties. This could
hurt the Dutch economy or put the Netherlands at a disadvantage
in international negotiations. In such a scenario, critical tasks of
organisations, such as distributing energy, carrying out financial
transactions or providing education, can no longer be carried out.
Besides this direct impact, breaches of cyberspace also have a wider
impact. This includes, for example, the costs of investigating and
repairing systems, the potential need to rebuild infrastructure and
being forced to temporarily fall back on analogue alternatives.
Breaches of cyberspace can also impair citizens’ and organisations’
confidence in processes. Furthermore, individual states and
organisations often have only very limited capabilities to increase
their resilience to outages and the abuse of cyberspace. For
example, they often lack insight into the levels of resilience in
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents