world, affecting some fifty million people, from the US Pentagon to the UK Parliament, and
costing an estimated US$10 billion worth of damages in a matter of hours.9 The bug was
programmed to replace all files with media extensions (images, documents, mp3s, etc.) with
copies of itself, and then to send an identical email to all of the contacts of a victim’s Outlook
address book.10
Law enforcement traced the bug to the Philippines and identified a Filipino, Onel de
Guzman, largely on the basis of an unusually heavy volume of data traffic to a computer
located in the home of de Guzman’s sister. The FBI and other authorities moved to take
action against de Guzman. However, progress and prosecution was stymied by the fact
that the Philippines did not, at that time, have laws governing computer crime (attempts
were made to prosecute him under theft, but the charges were dropped due to insufficient
evidence).11 As such, the extradition treaties were rendered ineffectual due to the
requirement of “dual criminality” (see section 2 A, above).
The “Love Bug” shows the limits of traditional notions of jurisdiction in cybercrime: an
individual released a destructive antigen into cyberspace, causing damage and deleterious
effects in some twenty countries, but, because he was physically located in a jurisdiction that
had not criminalized such behavior, no action could be taken by the affected states.
II. Adaptive Jurisdiction Principles
Faced with the increasingly limited applicability of the traditional notion of jurisdiction to
cybercrime, a series of adaptations have been developed, based principles of (A) territoriality, (B)
active nationality, (C) passive nationality, (D) protection and (E) universality.
A. Principle of Territoriality
The principle of territoriality, the notion underpinning so much of our understandings of law, and
especially for international law,12 is the base principle for traditional claims of jurisdiction, as well as
the basis upon which adaptive notions of jurisdiction are built.13 The traditional understanding of
jurisdiction operates on the conceit that the state inherently has complete jurisdiction over crimes
occurring in its territory.14
This principle has been extended to nebulous yet quasi-territorial areas. Under the law of the flag
(or the “flag principle”), vessels on the “high seas” (and those operating them) “possess” the
nationality of the flag that borne by the vessel15 (or where it is registered),16 and thus that state has
jurisdiction.17 In 2014, the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) deemed cyberspace to be
sovereign domain akin to air, land and sea.18
Page 123 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents