The principle of territoriality has been used in other ways to alter traditional fixed methods
and notions. For example, in one celebrated conflicts of law case, a New York court accepted
jurisdiction over a tort matter that occurred outside of its territory, but in which both parties were
New York residents; more interestingly, the court went on to apply New York law rather than the law
of the place of the tort, as traditional rules would have dictated: the court made this deviation on
the logic that the affected interests were in New York and had nothing to do with the other state.19
Similarly, under an adaptive understanding of the principle of territoriality, a cybercrime “initiated”
in the territory of one state but launched “at” another state, or made to occur “in”, another state’s
territory gives the affected state jurisdiction.20
Another approach to this problem has been to broaden the notion of territoriality to extent to
actions occurring in whole or in part in the prosecuting nation’s territory.21 Such an “occurrence”
can be understood to include use of the affected state’s infrastructure. Thus, this approach would
give the state jurisdiction where both22 or either victim or perpetrator are physically located in the
state when the crime was committed,23 or when any part of the crime was committed, planned or
facilitated in that country.24
The principle of territoriality remains the principal basis for exerting jurisdiction over cybercrimes.
The Budapest Convention, for example, makes it mandatory for signatories to adopt, legislatively
or otherwise, all that is necessary for establishing jurisdiction over listed offences committed from
within the state’s physical territory.25
B. Principle of (Active) Nationality
Under the principle of nationality (or of active nationality), a sovereign may regulate the actions
of its nationals abroad.26 The principle is most typically invoked when a national commits a crime
in a foreign state, and is more commonly found in the civil law tradition than in the common law
tradition.27 Under this principle, nationals of a state are obliged to comply with that state’s domestic
law even when they are outside of its territory.28 When a national commits an offence abroad, the
state is obliged to have the ability to prosecute if that conduct is also an offence under the law of
the state in which it was committed.29 In the instance of cybercrime, the principle is often relevant
in child pornography cases, where the national attempts to perform the illegal action in a location
where it is not a crime with the intent of distributing the subsequent material in his or her home
country. The principle has less relevance in cybercrime than in other areas of criminal law as most
cybercrimes can be effectuated from the perpetrator’s home, while having cross border effects.30
C. Principle of Passive Nationality
The reciprocal of the principle of active nationality the principle of passive nationality (or passive
personality). This principle applies where the national is the victim rather than the perpetrator,
Page 124 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents