thereby giving the state jurisdiction over the crime by which its national is victimized. The principle
only takes on relevance when the entirety of the crime has occurred outside of the territory of
the state. The principle is a controversial one, as it not only aggressively expands the notion of a
state’s authority, but, in so doing, it also implies that the law of the state with territorial jurisdiction
is insufficient to remedy the wrong and incapable—or unwilling—to protect the interest of the
victimized national.31
Case 2.13: LICRA v. Yahoo!32 (France) and Yahoo! v. LICRA (USA)33
Plaintiffs, Union des Étudiants Juifs de France (“UEJF”) and La Ligue contre la Racisme et
l’Antisemitisme (“LICRA”), brought a civil action against the French and American entities
of Yahoo! over an internet auction of Nazi-period memorabilia under French criminal law,
the “wear[ing] or exhibit[ing]” of Nazi paraphernalia is prohibited.34 The French court of first
instance ruled that there were sufficient links with France to give the court full jurisdiction,
and proceeded to enjoin Yahoo! to take all necessary measures to dissuade and prevent
French users from accessing the material in question—in other words, to block access to the
online auction.35 Although the competence of the French court was challenged and appealed
in France, the original decision was upheld. Separate criminal proceedings in France were
dismissed and defendants acquitted on all criminal charges; that a verdict that was upheld on
appeal.
Following the French court decisions, Yahoo! brought suit in the United States, asking that
the French judgment be deemed without effect in the United States.36 The US District Court
for the Norther District of California instead found that the French court’s decision was
inconsistent with US constitutional guarantees of freedom of expression. However, the US
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed and remanded, with directions to dismiss the
action on the divided basis of lack of ripeness and of lack of personal jurisdiction.37
D. Protective Principle
The protective principle (also called the “security principle” and “injured forum theory”) is triggered
when the crime—effectuated from beyond the state’s territory—affects not just a national of the
state, but a national security interest (domestic or international), such as the proper functioning
of the government, or threatening the security of the state.38 It is closely related to competition
law’s “effects doctrine” (or, as it is also termed, the “implementation test”),39 which stipulates that
where the economic effects of the anticompetitive conduct experienced on the domestic market
are substantial, the affected state might exert jurisdiction over both foreign offenders and foreign
conduct.40 However, unlike both the effects doctrine and other forms of extraterritorial jurisdiction,
the protective principle is not performed in an ad hoc, case-by-case fashion, but is instead used as
Page 125 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents