Referenced in: § C. Procedural
Issues
1.
2.
This section focuses on investigative and
prosecutorial “procedural” issues; “due
process” issues are treated in § 5 A, infra.
In practice, procedural issues are
never entirely detached from the
substantive specification of an offense.
The specification of the elements and
seriousness of the offense are important
in determining whether cognizance it
taken of a suspected violation, and, if
so, what level of intrusiveness will be
permitted during investigation.
3.
See, e.g., Budapest Explanatory Report,
supra § 1 D, note 14, at para. 132 (“Not
only must substantive criminal law keep
abreast of these new abuses, but so must
criminal procedural law and investigative
techniques”).
4.
Tonya Putnam & David Elliot, Chapter
2- International Responses to Cyber
Crime, (Stanford: Hoover Institution
Press, 2001), pp. 1–2, at http://www.
hoover.org/sites/default/files/uploads/
documents/0817999825_35.pdf.
5.
For instance, the offender is based in one
or more different countries, the services
utilized are in different countries, the
technology protects is anonymous, the
communications are encrypted.
6.
7.
8.
Most tellingly, it bears emphasizing
that e-evidence is information stored
or transmitted in binary form (“0” and
“1”), and that that binary code assigns a
bit string to each symbol or instruction.
Such being the case, the evidence is in
many ways both illusionary and illusive:
the “original” evidence can be identically
copied with no difference between the
two except the time of their existence,
and its integrity can be very easily
compromised. For deeper discussion, see
supra § 2 B.
US Dept. of Justice, Searching and
Seizing Computers and Obtaining
Electronic Evidence in Criminal
Investigations (Washington: Office
of Legal Education, 2009) [hereafter,
“Searching and Seizing e-Evidence”],
at https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/
files/criminal-ccips/legacy/2015/01/14/
ssmanual2009.pdf; UNODC Cybercrime
Study, supra § 1 C, note 7.
9.
Thomas K. Clancy, Cyber Crime and
Digital Evidence: Materials and Cases
(New York: Lexisnexis, 2011); Cameron S.
D. Brown, “Investigating and Prosecuting
Cyber Crime: Forensic Dependencies and
Barriers to Justice,” International Journal
of Cyber Criminology, Vol. 9, Issue1 (2015),
Issue 55, pp. 66–67.
ITU Understanding Cybercrime, supra § 1
B, note 1, at 251–56.
10. See, e.g., Budapest Explanatory Report,
supra § 1 D, note 14, at para. 12 (“[T]
here are some differences with respect to
the search of computer data, which may
necessitate different or special procedural
provisions to ensure that computer data
can be obtained in a manner that is
equally effective as a search and seizure
of tangible data. […] Some changes may
be required to domestic law to ensure
that intangible data can be searched
and seized. […D]ue to the connectivity
of computer systems, data may not be
stored in the particular computer that is
searched, but such data may be readily
accessible to that system. […Allowing
such searches may] require new laws
to permit an extension of the search to
where the data is actually stored (or the
retrieval of the data from that site to
the computer being searched), or the
use traditional search powers in a more
coordinated and expeditious manner at
both locations.”). See, e.g., American Law
Institute, “Model Code of Cybercrime
Investigative Procedure,” at http://www.
crime-research.org/library/Model_Code.
htm.
11. USC Title 18, §§ 3123 (1986).
12. USA PATRIOT Act, supra § 1 C, note 10.
13. See supra § 1 B.
14. Korea: Criminal Procedure Act, No.
12784 (15 Oct. 2014) [hereafter “Korean
Criminal Procedure Act”], at http://
elaw.klri.re.kr/eng_mobile/viewer.
do?hseq=33081&type=sogan&key=9 (in
English), Art. 106(3), (“Where the object to
be seized is a computer disc or other data
storage medium similar thereto […], the
court shall require it should be submitted
after the data therein are printed out or
it is copied within the specified scope
of the data stored: Provided, That the
data storage medium or such may be
seized, when it is deemed substantially
impossible to print out or copy the
specified scope of the data or deemed
substantially impracticable to accomplish
the purpose of seizure.”).
15. Regarding the need for a formalization of
computer forensics, see Ryan Leigland &
Axel W. Krings, “A Formalization of Digital
Forensics,” International Journal of Digital
Evidence, Vol. 3, Issue 2 (2004), p. 2.
16. Michell Lange & Kristin Nimsger,
Electronic Evidence and Discovery
(Chicago: Section of Science &
Technology Law, American Bar
Association, 2004), p. 6.
17. With regard to developments, see
Danny Abramovitch, “A Brief History of
Hard Drive Control,” Control Systems
Magazine, EEE, Vol. 22, Issue 3 (2002), p.
28 et seq.; Tom Coughlin, Dennis Waid,
& Jim Porter, “The Disk Drive, 50 Years
of Progress and Technology Innovation,”
Coughlin Associates, (2005), at www.
tomcoughlin.com/Techpapers/DISK%20
DRIVE%20HISTORY,%20TC%20Edits,%20
050504.pdf.
18. Scott Giordano, “Electronic Evidence and
the Law,” Information Systems Frontiers,
Vol. 6, No. 2 (2006), p. 161; Stephen
Willinger & Robin Wilson, “Negotiating
the Minefields of Electronic Discovery,”
Richmond Journal of Law & Technology,
Vol. 10, Issue 5 (2004), at http://jolt.
richmond.edu/v10i5/article52.pdf.
19. Malaga, “Requirements for the
Admissibility in Court of Digital
Evidence,” in: Syllabus to the European
Certificate on Cybercrime and
E-Evidence, (2008), p. 208 et seq.
20. See, e.g., Searching and Seizing
Computers and Obtaining Electronic
Evidence in Criminal Investigations,
supra note 7; US Dept. of Justice,
Criminal Division, Office of Professional
Development and Training, “Federal
Guidelines for Searching and Seizing
Computers,” Bureau of National
Affairs, Criminal Law Reporter, Vol. 56
(1994), p. 5, at https://epic.org/security/
computer_search_guidelines.txt; Korean
Constitution, Art.12(1) & 12(3); Korean
Criminal Procedure Act, supra note 14, at
Arts. 114 & 215. See also infra § 2 C, case
2.9.
21. In US law, contraband, an instrumentality
of a crime or fruits of crime and therefore
may be physically seized. See Rule 41,
Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, at
https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcrmp/
rule_41. See also Giordano, supra note 18.
22. Ibid.
23. Ibid., at 71.
24. See, e.g., United States v. Huitt, 2007 WL
2355782, at *4, (D. Idaho 2007).
Page 148 | Chapter 2 | End Notes
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents