B. The Law of Evidence
The law of evidence, a procedural body of law, governs how various forms of proof of misdoing
are presented and evaluated, typically for presentation at trial.5 It consists of rules and procedures
governing the proof of a particular set of facts in issue.6 Matters of evidence are concerned with
presenting evidence supporting both the occurrence of events, and the implicated actors thereto.
For the purpose of legal proceedings, the concept of electronic evidence may have specific
recognition, or it may be admitted as analog evidence, such as in the form of a document, with the
meaning of what constitutes a document invariably extending to anything recorded in any form,
which must be right.7
From a legal perspective, electronic evidence needs to be:
1
Admissible, meaning that it conforms to legal rules;
2 Authentic, meaning that the evidence can be shown to be what the proponent claims it is;
3 Complete, meaning that it tells the whole story and not just a particular perspective;
4 Reliable, meaning that there is nothing about how the evidence was collected and handled
that casts doubt about its authenticity and veracity; and
5
C
redible, meaning that it is believable and understandable by a court.8
From a legal perspective, e-evidence can be defined not only on the basis of what it is—that is, as
the legal object constituted by data expressed in electronic format, as defined above—, but also as
a construct—that is, the representation of facts or acts legally relevant to the matter and conducted
by electronic means. Regardless of which aspect is considered, technical and legal analysis is
required in order to show how the evidence was obtained, as well as how to interpret it and show
how it pertains to the criminal matter.
C. Computer Forensics
Computer forensics plays an essential role in both (1) investigating cybercrime and (2) identifying,
collecting and preserving evidence.
1. Investigating Cybercrime
Investigating a cybercrime may involve invasive surveillance, as followed up by search and seizure.9
Prior to any search and seizure, however, investigations typically begin by proving that the suspect
had the ability to commit the crime. Although surveillance of suspects can reveal a great deal—
for instance, establishing the requisite know-how, or observing unusually heavy volumes of data
traffic to a computer that incriminates the alleged perpetrator10—, those initial suspicions and
circumstantial evidence must be corroborated.
Page 111 | Chapter 2 | § D. Evidentiary Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents