Regardless of the crime, traces of the perpetrator and how the crime was committed are left
behind.11 Forensics is the use of scientific tests or techniques in connection with the detection of
crime.12 Computer forensics refers to the systematic collection of data and analysis of computer
technology and information with the purpose of searching for e-evidence.13 Generally utilized
after the commission of the crime,14 computer forensics is a major part of cybercrime investigation.
Indeed, its centrality to the investigation’s success emphasizes the need for training and capacitybuilding in this area, as well as the sharing of resources and of information.15 While forensic
techniques in traditional crimes typically rely upon physical evidence—DNA, splatter patterns,
chemical analysis16—computer forensic techniques rely upon a variety of digital sources—emails,
connection logs, various metadata17—; each present their own unique challenges.18
Computer evidence comes in a variety of forms and can be found in a variety of places. Regardless
of the location of that evidence—be it on a perpetrator’s hard drive, in the records of a third party
provider (such as an ISP) or in fragments scattered around the world (such as in cloud computing)—,
procedures are required for gaining access. As already discussed, traditional search and seizure
procedures already in existence must be adapted to make the accommodate the novelties of
cybercrime investigations (see section 2 C, above). Following search and seizure, forensic experts
are required to examine not only hardware and software but also the various and sundry metadata.19
2. Identifying, Collecting & Preserving Evidence
Collecting digital or e-evidence requires diverse and complex technical skills. For instance,
techniques for accessing and retrieving evidence stored on hard drives differ drastically from those
required to intercept data being transmitted.20 Moreover, time is often of the essence, both due
to the fragility of the evidence, and given the immediacy of actions taken in cyberspace, often
requiring quick decision-making off of investigators. For instance, a common question is whether
investigators should shut down a running computer system. There are reasons for going in either
direction: for instance, shutting down the system might be necessary in order to prevent alteration
of digital information and thereby preserve the integrity of relevant e-evidence.21 That said, “pulling
the plug” may actually result in the loss of other evidence, such as temporary files that require
programs, applications or internet connections to be maintained and kept running or operating.
However, power disruption can activate encryption,22 thereby hindering access to stored data,23
and, if the appropriate security is put in place, possibly even resulting in the destruction of digital
information. Additionally, even after the decision has been reached, the appropriate investigative
procedures must be followed.
First responders, who undertake the first steps to collect e-evidence, bear a significant responsibility
for the entire investigation process, as any wrong decision can have a major impact on the ability to
preserve relevant evidence.24 If they make wrong decisions on preservation, important traces may
be lost. Forensic experts need to ensure that all relevant evidence is identified.25 Doing as much is
often difficult, with various tricks employed by offenders, such as hiding files in separate storage
device or scattered across the cloud in order to prevent law enforcement from finding and analyzing
Page 112 | Chapter 2 | § D. Evidentiary Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents