I. Concept of Due Process
The concept of due process of law and respect for the rule of law is recognized as fundamental
to both common and civil law systems.2 Many constitutions offer explicit due process guarantees.
For example, the Fifth and the Fourteenth Amendments to the US Constitution provide that “No
person shall be […] deprived of life, liberty or property, without due process of law.” Likewise, Korea,
which has a more civil law-oriented legal system, has similar clauses in its Constitution. Specifically,
Article 12 of the Korean Constitution provides that,“All citizens shall enjoy personal liberty. No
person shall be arrested, detained, searched, seized or interrogated except as provided by Act.
No person shall be punished, placed under preventive restrictions or subject to involuntary labor
except as provided by Act and through lawful procedures. Warrants issued by a judge through due
procedures upon the request of a prosecutor shall be presented in case of arrest, detention, seizure
or search.”
In terms of the scope of due process, both substantive and procedural due process components
are recognized by the Supreme Court of the United States.3 Unsurprisingly, greater emphasis is
put on the procedural due process aspects of judicial proceedings in that context. However, due
to the potential for the loss of liberty if convicted, there is a substantial need for due process in
criminal cases because of the potential for the sovereign coercive is bringing its power to bear on
individuals.4
This section will discuss peculiar due process issues in investigation and prosecution of cybercrimes
and also review relevant arguments linked with the Budapest Convention.
II. Due Process in Investigation & Prosecution of Cybercrimes
General due process requirements apply when investigating and prosecuting crimes include, inter
alia, the right of the defendant to confront his or her accuser, the right to counsel and the right to a
speedy trial. As mentioned, this section focuses on more specific and frequent cybercrime-related
issues, notably (A) imbalance of obtaining evidence and (B) search and seizure.
A. Obtaining Evidence
Issues of the admissibility of evidence in court, such as the requirements of authenticity, integrity
and reliability of digital evidence, have already been discussed (see sections 2 C and 2 D,
above). From a procedural due process point of view, even though cybercriminals operate in
a sophisticated and cross-border environment, there can still be a power imbalance between
investigative agencies and defendants: compared to individual defendants, investigators and
prosecutors have more negotiating power, especially when searching and securing evidence.
Page 172 | Chapter 4 | § A. Due Process
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents