Moreover, once an investigation reaches the prosecutorial phase, there is likely more inculpatory evidence in favor of the state than exculpatory evidence in favor of the defendant. Yet justice systems, beholden to the rule of law, need to be fair and neutral. B. Search & Seizure If the search and seizure violates the criminal procedure law and/or the constitutional law in principle, the evidence that is seized ought to be excluded from evidence. In the United States, there are various federal statues which set a limit on the investigatory power: ƒƒ Wiretap Act (19 USC § 2510): This Act governs the seizure of the content of digital messages. It places a general prohibition on intercepting the contents of wire, oral or electronic communications. Violation of the Act can cause criminal punishment or/and civil damages. Only by an order of a federal judge can interception be permitted or justified.5 ƒƒ Pen Register and Trap and Trace Statue (18 USC § 3121): This statute governs the seizure of real-time traffic data—dialing, routing, addressing and signaling information provided by a communications service provider. It generally prohibits the nonconsensual real-time acquisition of non-content information by any person by wire or electronic communication unless a statutory exception applies.6 ƒƒ Electronic Communications Privacy Act (18 USC § 2701): This Act protects individuals’ privacy and proprietary interests, which applies when law enforcement officials seek to obtain records about a customer or subscriber from a communication service provider.7 Specifically, it looks to protecting stored communications. ƒƒ Fourth Amendment of US Constitution: This constitutional provision—part of the original set of amendments to the US Constitution, collectively known as the Bill of rights—is construed as prohibiting the search or seizure of an individual or their property, unless a warrant is first obtained from a judge or the circumstances fall within very limited number of situations where a warrant is deemed unnecessary.8 The United Kingdom has recently broadened the surveillance capacities of its law enforcement authorities, relying on a so-called “double-lock” procedure to limit potential government abuse: In the United Kingdom, the Investigatory Powers Act 20169 significantly expanded the surveillance power of law enforcement, granting authorities unprecedented surveillance powers to access private data of individuals.10 The controversial law11 was advanced to support law enforcement agencies in prevention and prosecution of modern crimes.12 Specifically, the Act requires communication service providers to preserve their customers’ data for a year. In addition to the data retention obligations, businesses are legally mandated to remove any encryption that interferes with warrants. Moreover, the Act enables authorities to intercept and store all forms of data, even Page 173 | Chapter 4 | § A. Due Process Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents