years, Loong, who had initially posed as a director of a music festival, made harassing phone
calls and sent some 5,000 emails, in addition to creating hate groups on Facebook and
Twitter and a slanderous blog, through which he made threats of rape and physical violence
against Ramm and her family. Loong even made bomb threats to the opera companies that
engaged her. A promising opera singer, Ramm’s career was destroyed and she suffered
serious psychological episodes, including contemplating suicide, eventually being diagnosed
with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).70
For six years, Ramm was rebuffed by the FBI, the New York Police Department and other
government agencies, and was met with a lack of interest by Singaporean authorities (where
cyberstalking was not criminalized). Eventually, Ramm hired a cybercrime expert with links
to the US Secret Service (USSS), who was able to navigate the US and Singaporean legal
systems.
Eventually, Loong admitted to thirty-one counts of criminal intimidation between 2005 and
2011 (as well as confessing to having harassed two other foreigners (a Ukranian violinst
and the German boyfriend of a Hungarian pianist) and a Singaporean business woman;
to criminally trespassing at St. James Church; and to stealing biscuits from the Church’s
kindergarten. After considering the aggravating factors, the Singapore Subordinate Court
determined that Loong made “vicious threats of violence and extremely vulgar email rants”
against Ramm that was tantamount to “mental assault” as well as repeated acts of aggressive
intrusion, and sentenced Loong to thirty-six months in prison (nine months jail for each of
the fourteen counts, with four of the sentences running consecutively) and to pay a fine of
S$5,000.71
Taking almost nine years, the conviction makes for the first successful prosecution of an
international cyberstalking case.72 In the words of the presiding judge, the case is “a timely
reminder that harassment laws need to keep pace with changes in technology and the
pervasive use of the Internet and social media”. Singapore has subsequently criminalized
cyber-bullying and -stalking.73
B. Combatting Cyberstalking at the Societal Level
Cyberstalking has only relatively recently been seen as a serious crime, and is still not universally
criminalized. In 2014, a European Union-wide survey across the twenty-eight Member States
found that only eleven had specific anti-stalking laws.74 Since then, the CoE’s Istanbul Convention
has substantially worked to harmonize laws on violence against women across Europe, including
stalking (without distinction between physical- and cyber-stalking).75 In the United States, stalking
became an issue of social concern in the 1990s76; the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
criminalized stalking under US federal legislation.77 The first jurisdiction in the United States to
Page 86 | Chapter 2 | § B. Criminalized Conduct
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents