criminalize cyberstalking was California in 199978; thereafter, in 2000, language was added to the
federal law, VAWA, to include cyberstalking.79 While legal definitions vary across jurisdictions,80
thereby complicating prosecution and investigation,81 courts have facilitated legislative hiccups by
extending existing, traditional statutes to include electronic tools.82
Case 2.5: United States v. Baker (USA)83
Defendants, Abraham Jacob Alkhabaz, a.k.a. Jake Baker, and Arthur Gonda, were prosecuted
for electronic mail messages involving sexual and violent behavior towards women and girls.
Baker also posted a reputedly-fictional story describing the torture, rape and murder of a
young woman sharing the name of one of Baker’s classmates at the University of Michigan.
Although the true identity and whereabouts of Gonda, who was operating from a computer
in Ontario, Canada, are still unknown, Baker was arrested and charged under federal statute
18 USC § 875(c), which prohibits interstate communications containing threats to kidnap
or injure another person. The count that had been based on Baker’s story publication was
dismissed as protected as free speech under the First Amendment of the US Constitution.
The other charges, which were based on defendants’ email correspondence, and thus of a
private nature, were deemed not to constitute “true threats” by the district court. While the
US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld the District Court’s decision, it bears noting
that just what constitutes a “true threat” under US law remains unclear.84
Cyberstalking is frequently misconstrued as a crime lacking significance. In order to effectively
combat cyberstalking, the government must, first, build sufficient capacity in order to both conduct
proper investigations and to offer alleged victims the appropriate degree of psychological support
and understanding, and, second, actively work at breaking attitudinal barriers that make such
behavior acceptable.
Overcoming attitudinal barriers is also a necessary part of crime fighting. In stalking at large, and
in cyberstalking in particular, initial contact between perpetrator and victim is generally benign,
and may even be positive. Once communications turn disturbing, however, there is a tendency
of victims to immediately and spontaneously destroy the unwelcomed overtures; such behavior
by victims is typically motivated out of a sudden onset of fear or embarrassment. Unfortunately,
doing so can significantly hinder authorities in their investigating. As such, the battle against (cyber)
stalking begins by breaking attitudinal barriers and educating people so victims are not oblivious to
the signs of stalking and do not destroy evidence.
C. Examples of Good Practice in Prosecuting Cyberstalking
Page 87 | Chapter 2 | § B. Criminalized Conduct
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents